Crazy Girl Shin Bia

Description

Tough, lazy, money lover, yet beautiful high school student named Shin Bia. While she's thinking about the eras she suddenly falls into that ancient time period! She had to transform into an elegant lady and while she's there she faces quite an obstacle.

Type

Manhwa

Related Series

N/A

Associated Names

Crazy girl Shin Bi-Ah goes to the alien world!!

Nữ Hoàng Rắc Rối

Shin Bia - den skøre pige

Сумасшедшая девчонка Син Биа

크레이지걸 신비아 異界로 가다！！

크레이지걸 신비아 이계로 가다！！

Groups Scanlating

N/A

Latest Release(s)

N/A

Status in Country of Origin

19 Volumes (Complete)

Completely Scanlated?

Yes

Anime Start/End Chapter

N/A

User Reviews

N/A

Forum

1 topics, 5 posts

Click here to view the forum

User Rating

Average: 7.6 / 10.0 (443 votes)

Bayesian Average: 7.52 / 10.0

26%

14%

20%

14%

Last Updated

June 7th, 2023 10:16pm PDT - 3 years ago

Image [Report Inappropriate Content]

Genre

Action Adventure Comedy Drama Fantasy Harem Historical Martial Arts Romance Shoujo Slice of Life Supernatural
Search for series of same genre(s)

Categories

Log in to vote! Show all (some hidden)

Category Recommendations

Dinghai Fusheng Records (Novel)

Incubus Banishment ~I Was Banished From the Capital. But the More I Get Along With the Girls, the Stronger I Get~ (Novel)

Arifureta Shokugyou de Sekai Saikyou (Novel)

The Frost Flower Knight

Sora wa Akai Kawa no Hotori

Recommendations

Sora wa Akai Kawa no Hotori

Kanata Kara

Basara

Saver

Akagami no Shirayukihime

Author(s)

HWANG Mi-Ri

Artist(s)

HWANG Mi-Ri

Year

2008

Original Publisher

Samyang

Serialized In (magazine)

N/A

Licensed (in English)

English Publisher

N/A

Activity Stats (vs. other series)

Weekly Pos #726 (-26)

Monthly Pos #1784 (-160)

3 Month Pos #3230 (-440)

6 Month Pos #4875 (-457)

Year Pos #5853 (-1480)

List Stats

On 719 reading lists

On 477 wish lists

On 1262 completed lists

On 113 unfinished lists

On 335 custom lists

Note: You must be logged in to update information on this page.

Forum Posts Click to view the forum

Is the ending satisfying?

14 years ago

User Comments [ Order by time added ]

What a shame . . .

by Desposition
15 years ago

Rating: 4.5 / 10.0

I'm quite appalled at the number of high ratings for this manhwa. The plot was quite interesting for me, however. Another alter-ego in the past? Count me in... But that all bombed later on.

I've met many, many dumb, reckless manga/manhwa characters, but none have chased me away from a story as Shin Bia had.

I'm quite disappointed, actually. This one truly had me hooked. She was strong, independent in the beginning, but she started to become a total baboon later on. Had her intelligence lowered? I'm quite disgusted at her continuing actions of escaping. She truly has no thought for Prince Yoo-Baek's feelings.

And ah, Prince Yoo-Baek. Please, do not get me started on him. He was quite charming, but his ignorance for Shin Bia annoyed me, but that was one trait I let slide by. Prince Mu-Yeong was interesting, actually. But when he started to fall for her... Typical story line.

Shin Bia. Well, haven't I summarized her up already? An annoying, rude, idiotic, thoughtless, reckless excuse for a character. I know some girls from mangas/manhwas are stupid, but she truly repulsed me to the bitter end. I have never felt this extreme dislike for a character before, but there's a first time for everything.

All in all, I gave this up. My extreme dislike for Shin Bia ultimately made me lose interest in this particular story. What a shame. If Shin Bia acted with more intelligence, this story would have been good. My final comment on this is, 'If you can handle the stupidity, by all means, read this manhwa.'

• • • • •

Plot ; 4/5
Characters ; 3/5
Art ; 3.5/5

... Last updated 15 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes No

It's annoying

by ZL11
15 years ago

Rating: 3.0 / 10.0

Shin Bia has to be one of the most annoying "heroines" I have ever read in a manhwa, and there are quite a few annoying ones in the manhwa world. She's thrown into another world, but she's hostile to everyone. She's completely ungrateful, ill mannered, and often seems downright stupid. She doesn't think before acting, she doesn't listen to people who are trying to help her, and she constantly talks about strength, but it stupid about what it means to be strong. I can usually warm up to characters that come off rough at the beginning like she does, but her behavior is so atrocious and without justification that is just irritates me. All the other characters are more interesting, but she's like a fly in the ointment. It's really hard to get past what a stupid, arrogant, ungrateful little b*tch she is and enjoy any other elements of the story. She sucks as a character, and it ruined the story for me.

Was this comment useful? Yes No

was good :)

by purfect_kutie64
14 years ago

Rating: 9.5 / 10.0

spent a whole day to finish this manga. no matter the previous comments, crazy girl shin bia was a good read. it's like one of those stories that just grabs you. but there were so many things that i'd wished for while reading it. i wished that, while yoo-baek was all lovey dovey with shin bia during the first half of the series, she wouldn't be so stupid. also i would've liked to see yoo-baek and shin bia's child. lol typical but w/e. 😛

Was this comment useful? Yes No

This Manga is Awesome..

by glygly
15 years ago

Rating: 10.0 / 10.0

i don't know why some people think that this manhwa is no good or not satisfying. But for me i think this is really great! compared to other HMR's work, i think this manga is the best. It has a lot of bishies and the scenes weren't boring at all. I had really fun while reading this manhwa and Bia is the best protagonist in all HMR's work. Maybe sometimes she's annoying but that makes the manhwa good, well obviously the tittle is Crazy Girl Shin Bia of course she's bound to be crazy! LOL and about the ending i like it! so what if she didn't have a child its still good. and it doesn't leave you hanging like her other works..! so overall im satisfied! * a real good read 🙂 )

Was this comment useful? Yes No

something is missing...

by Di27
14 years ago

Rating: 9.9 / 10.0

it reminds me of "RED RIVER" which is my absolute fave but i dunno this story was first i thought i'l get bored of so will read in a span of a month but turned interesting very quickly.. but i cant help but feel there are a few gaps in the ending.. felt like it was rushed so instead of a 10 i give it a 9.9

Was this comment useful? Yes No

painfuL

by Seryphiel
16 years ago

Rating: N/A

u no, its one those manga/manhwa
where the plot is kinda crappy
but u just wanna no wat happens,
so u continue reading to see if it there's any
better development in the plot line
& the only thing keeping u baited is the promise of romance
but u wait.... and u wait.... and wait.....til it becomes painful to read >.<

... Last updated 16 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes No

Nice Serie

by lainbr
15 years ago

Rating: 9.0 / 10.0

I'm probably the only person that dont thing Bia is annoying. What should i say, I would prolly act as her in the same situation.

And hell! She is crazy and its the best thing from this Manhwa!

Was this comment useful? Yes No

She devolves further and further into stupidity

by moonmystery
6 years ago

Rating: 1.0 / 10.0

I was hooked at the beginning and thought Shin Bia's antics were funny, but her shticks soon got tiring to see. Characters seemed not to develop naturally, and author keeps going from 0 to 100 with no decent context to back that up. Everyone in Hwang Mi-Ri's world seems violent and psychotic. Most men seem rapey, and everyone seems violent except for some secretly plotting evil villainess pretending to be a shy damsel in distress. It's such a cliche. Pretty disappointed.

... Last updated 6 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes No

Funny and weird

by KittyTeea
14 years ago

Rating: 8.5 / 10.0

I'm at chapter 4, and I have to say that I rarely comment at such an early stage but I really have to.

For now I like Bia, what I don't get is the prince that was supposed to be in love with the other Bia, I mean they look the same yet he doesn't recognize her, only her pendant then he starts kissing her, is he retarded? Then he comes to the conclusion that she is the one with amnesia and that kissing is the cure. Oh well, could be worst, he could be both stupid and ugly, he's just stupid.

Edit1: Chapter 8 priceless, my rating will increase at least for that scene.

Edit2: I really enjoy this story, and I like Bia, although at times, ok all the time, is very rush and kinda self-centered. Chapter 59 is the first time she actually thinks about her surroundings and the situation she is in. But for some reason, right now, I'm more interested in the second prince and his fiancee (^w^), I want more emphasis on them.

Edit3: I'm at chapter 67 and up this point I have to admit that I like a lot more prince Mu-Yeong, than Yoo-Baek. And right now I'm rooting for him, what I dislike is that I'm sure that the mangaka will do something to make him lose face, and increase Yoo-Baek's popularity, cuz dah he's the main male lead.

Edit4: Chapter 77 it turned out I was right, what a surprise jeez. I really don't like this part.

Final Edit: The story was nice, not as good as Red River, but still ok. The art was absolutely gorgeous, my fav bishie was actually Mu-Yeong. As a side note I kinda wished that he would have been the one to end with Bia, he was by far the most developed character. As for Bia, despite the somewhat negative view of the other reviewers, I really liked her. She wasn't the smartest female lead, but at least she was strong and also fallowed her heart, which is a change if you think about all the goody-goody oh so pure and noble shoujo heroines. Finally Yoo-Baek was pretty much the knight in shining armor type of character, he had very few emotional moments, few weaknesses. He was perfect, which made him perfectly boring, that's why I prefered Mu-Yeong over him.
Oh well overall it was a nice read, and I really enjoyed it.

... Last updated 14 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes No

Likeable

by Rinola
15 years ago

Rating: 8.0 / 10.0

Although I've only read a few of Hwang Mi Ri's manhwas, I feel that this one was the only one that didn't eventually blur into one big general plotline with the rest of her manhwas. It definitely had comedy going for it and as the story went along it got easier to get hooked. Also, pretty traditional clothing 🙂 pro for anything.

That said, I will admit I took something like a 6 month break from this manga near the start because the plot just wasn't really moving and I restarted reading around chapter 65 - by then the plot had by far improved.

Another flaw was the lack of characters with depth. The guys all seemed to be waaaaaaaaaay too obsessed with Bia (sometimes borderline psychotically so) who in turn seemed to go through phases of being strong character, then weak character then strong character and then ends up in between the two?

For example, Mu-yeong is probably the best example of this. Fine, he was a womanizer and then falls deeply in love with Bia - they spend time together, he falls deeper in love, he goes off giving his countries secrets to her. Cute (well kind of). Then he goes and captures her and tortures her and makes her watch her love's nerves get chopped...O_O

When you look at the big picture, all you can wonder is how none of the characters just decided they had enough of her childish, bratty and rude behavior and just executed her. xD

The ending was also very 'meh'. It felt rushed and spontaneous considering the rest of the plot. But well, it was a dramatic ending I suppose.

But overall, it was likeable 🙂

Was this comment useful? Yes No

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ]