28 volumes is too long. I mean that's alright, but anyway I still think 8.7 is a bit over. It's probably almost that, maybe 8 even, but anyway.
Conclusion wasn't that great for me, there was plenty of time to develop yet I think there was way too much development open, some weren't even good. Ishigami (i think its the correct name?) had his hair prepared once and it looked great, probably one of the coolest characters I have ever seen even, surely of this whole manga too, but then it never repeats and the 1 time it does it's not as good, remains always with that lame hair over half his face lol. That's alright though but dude just gets rejected then he goes nowhere with Iino (is that her name right?)... I mean it did comply with the goal and description of this manga but well, I do prefer conclusions, but at least it wasnt much bitter as some mangas manage to do and ruin the whole thing just on a whim. Also, Iino was never told it was Ishigami who wrote that message to her, why not? Why not finish the thing that you started lol.
For me real vote would be 8 or 7, some points actually more but some others nowhere near. Also, I would say this manga is closer to Shounen perhaps, it's not really that grown/adult/realistic in my opinion. But I guess the original didnt have furigana so its seinen?
And well the author is male, a lot of things arent really realistic to the females perspective. I would say he nailed it, though, when Kaguya just suddenly rejected Shirogane once the situation got a little messy and her old "love interest" came around. Bitter taste on that, but at least there was some competition, better than nothing at all.
Dude just gets a lot of money out of nowhere too, there's no way reality goes like that. He also dreams of getting back his father's company? But isnt his father a rich youtuber now? He was even driving a Ferrari or something similar in the end.
It's male fantasy, with silly development. I mean it's an alright read. It's difficult to take it any serious though of course, it's just man's dream. Even the way Kei rejects her mom in the end is like a male's dream.
For male readers if you want the real deal in terms of romance, find something from a female author, they might not nail perfectly the male side but they definitely do with the woman's. If you want an actual Seinen or adult story, probably gotta find something else too.
Ah, was gonna comment on Fujiwara but dont want to be fatphobic, I just find it unrealistic that she would reject that dude and then say she dreams of dating a sumo wrestler, even if she's a joker lol. Seems just to please part of the readers. It's just manga anyway so I guess I should stop taking it serious. Getting immersed in 28 volumes does that maybe.
For last, a bit lame that they fight over the inheritance with the old man still alive, at least they were "honest"(?) in this regard, but they definitely should've spent more time with their father instead of just fighting over it then just waiting him die?? I mean, that's pretty damn shameful. But I guess it's not unusual.
Forgot: Kaguya inherited billions of dollars (considering currency conversion from yen) but she wants to be a photographer studying in an USA university? Going around like that? The whole thing made no sense, thinking about it. There is no way they would be able to burn that testament like that too lol. There is no way in hell their father would let his 4 children mess about like that. Alright, it's just manga, but I think a minimal sense of realistic view wouldn't bother for a manga that is meant to be for adults (Seinen)