My reason for the high rating is because Sakira gets the theme pat down. The paneling is quite creative, there is much action packed into this, and the dialogues perfectly reflect the characters as two muscled idiots who are deeply in love with each other. The humour is on the light side, of the slap-stick variety, and the artwork is detailed and enjoyable if you like bara. Plus, the chibis are super cute.
The reason that I am not super into it though, is because I am in the mood to read something more atmospheric, with depth, and attention to small details such as Amadare no Koro. Or, the work of TOKITA Honoji, which as in the case of Tadatada Suki to Iu Dake de is quite atmospheric and endearing.