banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Manga Info
 
ALL A B C D E F G H I J K L M N O P Q R S T U V W X Y Z
Reborn as a Scholar   
Login to add items to your list, keep track of your progress, and rate series!
Description
A martial artist, claiming himself to be a "murderer" is defeated by a suicide attack in battle and is reborn as a first born child to a local lord. Having a fresh start, a warm family and a little sister to protect - he decides to become a better person in his new life.

Original Webtoon

Official Translation:
English, Indonesian, Japanese, S.Chinese

Type
Manhwa

Related Series
N/A

Associated Names
Reinkarnasi Sang Pendekar
The Scholar's Reincarnation
The Scholarly Reincarnation
学士再生
武人転生史
학사재생

Groups Scanlating
Hatigarm Scans
Mango Translation's
RESET SCANS
Meraki Scans
More...

Latest Release(s)

Status
in Country of Origin
198 Chapters (Ongoing)

Part 1 S1: 37 Chapters (1~37)
Part 1 S2: 39 Chapters (38~76)
Part 2 S1: 34 Chapters (77~110)
Part 2 S2: 39 Chapters (111~149)
Part 2 S3: 49 Chapters (150~198)
Part 3 : TBD

Completely Scanlated?
No

Anime Start/End Chapter
N/A

User Reviews
N/A

Forum

User Rating
Average: 7.9 / 10.0 (265 votes)
Bayesian Average: 7.75 / 10.0
10
 
 22%
9+
 
 17%
8+
 
 26%
7+
 
 17%
6+
 
 8%
5+
 
 4%
4+
 
 2%
3+
 
 1%
2+
 
 0%
1+
 
 3%

Last Updated
September 5th 2022, 7:02pm


Genre

Categories

Category Recommendations

Recommendations
N/A

Author(s)

Artist(s)

Year
2016

Original Publisher

Serialized In (magazine)
KakaoPage (Kakao)
Kakao Webtoon (Daum)

Licensed (in English)
Yes

English Publisher

Activity Stats (vs. other series)
Weekly Pos #395 increased(+59)
Monthly Pos #588 increased(+4)
3 Month Pos #628 increased(+129)
6 Month Pos #818 increased(+213)
Year Pos #818 decreased(-368)

List Stats
On 1875 reading lists
On 254 wish lists
On 20 completed lists
On 53 unfinished lists
On 288 custom lists

Note: You must be logged in to update information on this page.

No topics currently in the forum, view the forum or add a new topic now.

tickmark preload xmark preload xmark preload
User Comments  [ Order by usefulness ]
You must login to comment for this series! Register an account.
 
avatar
Bits are interesting  
by ciel_bleu
July 18th, 2022, 11:49pm
Rating: N/A
MC is too OP and a Gary Stu. His personality is also bland. But i like how he helps other characters grow. The author has done a good job with respect to the interesting side characters. In fact Jin Muyoung is STELLAR as a character. I'm reading this story for him.

... Last updated on July 25th, 2022, 7:45am
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
Nice start but too OP and too many golden fingers later on.  
by theliongirl
January 2nd, 2022, 10:24am
Rating: 7.0  / 10.0
As of chapter 188:

The slice of life is nice, I really like the family and the mc himself. Not perverted, not overly obsessed with justice to the point of saying "all killing is bad" or something like that, not an idiot, but a realistic good guy. I also quite like the love interest - she's pretty cool, and I really liked the scenes they had together. Some of their dialogue made up my favorite scenes from this webtoon.

The little sister surprised me; it's a breath of fresh air to have such a strong (non-sexualised) female character in a story targeted towards men. It seems like reviewer ohkimch left off where the mom told her to learn some "feminine" things (understandable for women in this time period) but she comes back after that arc, and the next arc is her going out on a martial arts journey (with her brother's supervision). Yeah their parents make them learn what's expected of them (scholarly arts for the mc and feminine arts for the sister) but once they've done that their parents support their children in what they want to do. (Also worth noting that a strong (female) character isn't just based on whether they can fight or not).

The MC does act a little bit childish when he's a kid, and I agree with that narrative choice (the romance would feel a lot creepier otherwise). He's truly been reborn and it feels like it; just because he has some memories of his past life doesn't mean that his brain is fully developed. Also, in his past life he wasn't some old grandpa like one reviewer said, he actually seemed to have died pretty young? No age is mentioned but I'd say in his early 20's? Early 30's tops.

The story does get a little bit boring after he grows up; I don't feel like there's enough struggle shown. Everything happens smoothly for them, and any bumps are easily overcome. I really want to see him deal with failure.

There's some set up for stronger enemies and some plot about his reincarnation so hopefully something good will end up happening with that.

Other than that the other problem I have is with lack of explanation and motivations that don't seem realistic. It feels like things jump around a bit? I think might partly be due to the translation not being clear and partly because some scenes and information from the novel didn't make it into the adaptation (haven't read the novel but some of the reviews do mention that this is a problem with the adaptation).

I'd give it an 8 at the start and then it drops down to a 7. It seems like there's still a lot left to go so hopefully it gets a little better and this is just the boring point in the story.
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
Decent  
by tiankioo
October 18th, 2021, 9:37pm
Rating: 6.0  / 10.0
Interesting start, seasons 3 and 4 are boring, but it picks back up afterward at the end of season 4 and start of season 5. Guy below me is a massive chode. Obviously, your opinion is the only correct one and anyone else is an idiot.

... Last updated on October 18th, 2021, 11:26pm
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
All of the top comments are idiots. Here is why  
by Trek184
March 12th, 2021, 1:33am
Rating: N/A
Okay, so even the top comments that "like the story" dont appear to have read since they say things that straight up Aren't true. The main character reveals his identity as a reincarnator to a number of former allies and enemies. Directly contracting the top comments. I won't argue with the people who say the story is bland, I dont think it is but that's a taste thing. I think slice of life is bland and repetitive but others don't. See what I'm getting at here?


Mainly I want to make clear that the MC's reincarnation is a major ongoing plot point. Previously he was feared and hated and now the he has spent over a decade with a loving family he has changed.

To the person who said that once he begins to travel the story goes stale... I declare you an idiot.
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
Bland story, boring characters and cringy MC  
by deathcoy
September 17th, 2020, 9:31am
Rating: 5.0  / 10.0
Theres a couple of demonic cultivator master reincarnated and became the good guy but with PTSD kinda manga & novels out there but this one is different in that it has a slice of life mixed in.

I generally don't like the bad guy turn over a new leaf and maybe the past catches up to him, that whole shenanigan. The whole story and premise more often than not feels so contrived with boring narrative that gets pigeonholed into the cliche plot development troupes. Furthermore righteous & upright MCs that only kill to protect but shielded by incredulous plot armor are usually the most one dimensional characters with narrow character development, are immature and naive. Plot and all the characters can only go down 1 predictable way.

Art is really good and i do somewhat enjoy the slice of life segments and banter though they are cringe worthy at times. However the plot, the character development for MC and supporting cast end up lacking, reasons mentioned above. Moreover manhwa dwells too much on the righteousness & justice plus the greater power, greater responsibility debate, its annoying shounen level philosophical crap. I guess author tried to live up to the 'Scholar' in the manhwa title but the execution is pretty bad, i'd describe it as immature.

Theres also the fact when MC reincarnates(still retains memories etc), he somehow regressed into a retard childish personality(and mentally too). Can you imagine a 100 year old grandpa trying to act cute like a friggin child? Cringe as hell, it gets better as he grew up, barely, but damn he is still childish trying to be daddy's boy even as an grown ass adult(i kid you not!!!). Seriously whut?!?! Gave me fatal goosebumps. This is my greatest pet peeve with this manhwa, a grown man with decades of experience, harden personality, went through lots of tempering and hardship, stepped into the boundary of the highest power etc, just lost his mind and turned into a cringed filled abomination of a childish immature brat, its disgusting and repulsive. The author wanted to go for a carefree, happy go lucky character with comedic elements but he missed the mark by a few lightyears. If theres a reason not read this manhwa, this is definitely it!!!

This also means the plot moves at a snail's pace as quite a lot of chapters are dedicated to the growing up phase and especially slice of life episodes. Also, author should have just dropped the reincarnation theme, cos usually it ends up being an afterthought and don't get much attention later on.

That said i do like the creative ways the MC plays around with his opponents and makes a fool of them but thats the only thing i like about him. Also the state of the murim world is pretty much at peace, different from the chaotic & perilous murim in other manga/novels. It is a refreshing change but also means that story gets quite boring and dull because well, its too peaceful cos nothing much happens. In my honest opinion, author should have squeezed in more political turmoil and power struggle in the shadows(plot is really begging for it) to make the story actually feel like its progressing and also to add some spicy to the already bland storyline.

As a light hearted martial world story with a side of slice of life, this is a barely OK read. If you expect a more engaging story or looking for something serious or different, then you'll be severely disappointed. The concept has potential but the execution is horrible.

... Last updated on September 17th, 2020, 11:50pm
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
Boring  
by rorikon
October 31st, 2019, 5:47pm
Rating: 4.0  / 10.0
I don't understand what all the praise is about. I read 25 chapters and nothing really happened. I don't care to read a slice of life about a young lord. Also the main character acts way different than his supposed badass past.

... Last updated on November 8th, 2019, 7:10pm
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
Very good  
by PZcolo
January 9th, 2019, 5:19am
Rating: 8.0  / 10.0
Definitely among the best reincarnation stories imo. The world is set in an old Korea style setting with impressive martial arts, so murim with no cultivation or magic (so far at least), so being the MC a reincarnation of the previous strongest man on earth and him starting practice martial arts sice 3-4 years old, its actually believable that he is very powerful when reaching adulthood, that's a big plus.
The story is progressing slowly which might be an issue for many but I don't mind and has been slowly setting the world and players of the story. There is clearly a story unfolding regarding the princess but it's too soon to know anything.
The second is that the MC is good, he doesn't go overboard bragging, doesn't go on killing rampages, is measured and hides his talent while doing the "dirty work" behind the scenes maintaining a low profile and he uses his brain for a change, also, he may sound like a goody two shoes but he's quite brutal at times and doesn't flinch from killing which is always a plus in my book. Furthermore, his interactions with other chars are interesting and feel natural, well except for that pathetic guard that should have been fired in the first 10ch or so. As for ohkimch comment regarding sexism, all I can say is "what do you expect?" this is not set in modern age, equality of gender didn't compute in those times, I would actually say they are quite liberal given the setting.
Last but not least, the artstyle is very good, the flow is good and the use of it for comedy is both funny and charming/cute.
All in all, this is one of my favourite manhwas at the moment and really hope it can keep it up.
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
Entertaining  
by ohkimch
April 11th, 2018, 4:46pm
Rating: 7.0  / 10.0
Art is nice, and the comedic expressions are very well-done.

Characters are well-developed as well. MC is an OP youngin', but there are valid reasons for his ridiculously strong martial arts. It's not like his skills just popped out with a simple "he's a genius" explanation.

That said, I do have to note his reincarnation really only comes into play regarding his otherwise inexplicable skills. His is kinda childish (through progressively less-so) and his attitude towards his parents in this life is respectful and surprisingly loving. (The family fluff is adorable and heart-warming.)

He does refrain from calling his mother "mommy" in favor of the more formal "mother" (which I suspect was '엄마' and '어머니' in the original), but otherwise, his age/experience does not carry much weight in his interpersonal relationships or general bearing. At least until he starts meeting people from his old life.

His mentality being closer to that of his current physical age is actually a blessing imo, though, because his love interest is around his age. If he behaved as his cumulative mental age, any romance would come off more than a bit pedo-/ephebophilic. So. It's better to think of him as a teen with the skills of a grown man.

His family and even some of the servants (especially Kyungho) have their own personalities, and their interactions with the MC don't feel forced or one-dimensional.

I even liked the female characterization (mainly represented by his younger sister) up until chapter 36. The rest of the female characters are the hackneyed "to be admired and protected, but rarely seen or heard" type, but Seoyeon's determination, eagerness, and aptitude in martial arts was refreshing.

It's not often you have a female character physically talented without her body being exploited for fanservice.

Then came the usual sexism - which was obviously disappointing after being spoiled(lol) by decent female characterization. The mother's character is wholly unremarkable and part for the course in terms of soft, genteel maternal figures in manga, and she is the one to ruin Seoyeon's character for me.

Spoiler (mouse over to view)
At chapter 36, her mother forces her to begin learning "feminine" things, like horticulture, cooking, and refreshments. At Seoyeon's understandable protests and insistence on continuing her physical training, their mother says, "You can, my daughter. You are a girl...be a girl even on the inside."


This, on its own, is irritatingly gender role restrictive and sexist, but worse in light of what the mother says to admonish the father about letting their son choose his own path in Chapter 5.

Spoiler (mouse over to view)
I'm speaking of when she says, "We should first respect his decision to pursue what he wants to." This is in response to the father seeming overexcited about his potential genius as a scholar (rather than a martial artist).

I will say that the female characterization is marginally better than what we normally see in vaguely historical fantasy manga/manhwa, but...

Well, chapter 36 was about when I dropped the series last time, in favor of Gosu, but hopefully I'll be glad to stick with it on the re-read.

Atm, would rate it about a 6 or 7?

Edit: glad I did a re-read, if only for the characterization and development of the main character. His personality is refreshing, too, in terms of shounen archetypes. He's jovial, but not an idiot, and friendly, but not a pervert. It's super fun to see him curbstomp his adversaries, too.

... Last updated on April 11th, 2018, 6:36pm
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
avatar
Simply Glorious  
by firefox1234
February 17th, 2018, 5:44am
Rating: 10.0  / 10.0
Hats off to the author and artist for making a very entertaining manhwa! The premise is very simple but the execution is stellar. The characters may not seem that interesting but the interactions they have especially the with the MC gives them so much life! 50 chapters in and hoping to read another 200...

... Last updated on February 26th, 2018, 5:16am
Was this comment useful?  Yes tickmark  No xmark    
Show 
 per page 
You must login to comment for this series! Register an account.