Sometimes I wonder why my taste in manga is so limited and difficult to pinpoint. I’ve never been able to get into popular ones like Skip Beat, Kaichou wa Maid-sama, Fruits Basket, Hana Kimi, or Hana Yori Dango ect and I wonder why but I honestly couldn’t tell you precisely. At first when I skimmed Ouran, I thought it wasn’t going to be my type at all either, but upon revisiting it, it surprised me. Ever since I understood the real story, I’ve always firmly believed one thing:
Ouran High School Host Club is ingenious.
Why, you ask? I think the answer lies in the fact that it’s exactly what the manga universe needed at that time - a parody. Ouran pokes fun at all the overused and cliché plot devices/character types used in shoujo manga and manages to build on it in a refreshing way. It's the mother of all subsequent shoujo parodies and still sits atop its pedestal today. Many will tell you that Ouran's the golden standard for comedy, but more than anything, I believe it's the golden standard for characters.
Haruhi is probably the only heroine I officially like in all of shoujo. After all those mangas I had been recommended and read in hopes of finding a strong female lead, here she was! Haruhi doesn’t physically “kick butt”, but she is intelligent, sarcastic, candid, down-to-earth, strong, calm, relatable and realistic. Amidst all the mayhem, Haruhi has to survive and rely on herself, yet she also manages to build real bonds with the eccentric members of the very host club that “enslaved” her. The whole set up of the host club makes it rather dramatic and exaggerated, but once again, its purpose is to show just how ridiculous some stories are when they mean it seriously. Haruhi might come off as a bit plain or boring to some, but I think the whole point of her personality is to show that everyone around her is somewhat crazy, but that she doesn’t lose herself to the insanity. Which, to be honest, is sometimes how we all feel about life. That’s not to say the host club is crazy in a bad way. Far from it. They are very well-placed in this type of story and each type of character exists for a reason. Together, they form one of the most memorable casts in all of shoujo.
Up until the time I read Ouran, I had only really seen the typical cold bishounen who is most likely a jerk but who also most likely is simply misunderstood and has a secret soft side, ect. I think that after my third manga, I had memorized the formula (which typically doesn’t exclude an airheaded, shallow heroine whose face becomes unbearably annoying past the fifth panel). Now, enter Tamaki – an outgoing, eccentric, narcissist whose greatest goal in life is to bring joy to ladies’ lives as a host. Tamaki is anything than what I would have expected in a shoujo male lead. He cries easily, is a bit naive (though academically impressive), dramatic, attention-seeking, clingy, loud, obnoxious but most definitely difficult to forget. In spite of his sad family backstory, he remained spirited and caring. Everything he did seemed passionate and random. However, his randomness was so well coordinated with Haruhi’s and the rest of the club’s reactions it just flowed perfectly. We have great character chemistry to thank for that.
The story is looser towards the beginning but it does get more focused as it delves into Tamaki’s family story. The romance aspect of the story strengthens too (but is by no means explicit as both leads are quite dense in that department). It’s nice to have a story that actually focuses on building trust and friendship before forming romantic relationships. The only thing you have to be prepared for is a lot of dialogue that is a slight drag to read through if you’re someone who really likes to get to the meat of things. Furthermore, the art isn’t exactly the best but Hatori has potential to improve greatly. And though I usually care greatly about art, this is one series where the rest makes up for it.
I’m sure I’m not the only one who has suffered from acute disappointment after a previously amazing story falls flat on its face at the end - it’s the most draining emotion ever. But one of the best things about Ouran is the fantastic, fulfilling ending. I’m all for happy endings. But I’ll still take a realistic ending over a happy one. Ouran manages to give us an ending that is both happy and realistic (well, realistic enough anyways). I held my breath until the end but inside I knew that I trusted the author to deliver, and she did. I had nothing to complain about when Ouran finished. Looking back through the series, everything was executed so well in terms of what the story was supposed to represent that I can honestly say this is one of the best I’ve ever come across. I haven’t given a rating higher than 7 up until now, but that is because I rate from a critical standpoint, so even though Ouran is not my favorite series, it has earned my highest rating so far.