It's been a long time since I last read a manga which is that good. Well, that's because of a few reasons.

First of all, I'd say that the drawing has something bewitching. It's not an accurate drawing but it somehow looks like art, like a painting. It reminds me of TOUME Kei's drawing. ( Sing Yesterday for me, Laments of the lamb, The Hour of the Mice... )

As for the storyline, no supernatural things, no action, no horror but a crude slice of life. It's not a " Soap Romance " as you often read or watch. To me, in this manga, NINOMIYA Hikaru shows both the pleasure and the harshness of Life.
Speaking of the sex scenes, in my opinion, they're really romantic ; Nothing to do with a hentai slaughter...

Finally, as it has already been said, I think that the characters are well developed and are very lovely in their own way.

To put it in a nutshell, it would be a pity not to read this manga especially if you like romance !

PS : Don't mind about my rating, i'm really severe with it.
PPS : Sorry for the bad english... Actually i'm a frog-eater...

... Last updated on June 10th, 2008, 5:20pm

Honeymoon Salad is a brooding romance story about the main character's relationship with two troubled women. It contains a sobering account of codependency, domestic violence, estrangement, and the depression that comes from contemporary urban adult life, into which the main characters' loves and joys are mixed. Despite some comic scenes with the main character early in the series, as well as the sex scenes, this is not a 'fun' story to read. The pessimism and themes of loss get more prevalent as the story goes on before culminating in a bizarre and dark ending.

Overall, I can't help but compare this story unfavorably to Nozoki Ana. Both are frank and at times sordid accounts of young adults' personal lives, but Honeymoon Salad doesn't bring the same range of emotions and experiences, while taking itself much more seriously. This failing affects it's eroticism as well, with many of its sex scenes being blatantly depressing. And while having a tiny cast is not in itself a bad thing, it ends up making it impossible to vary the tension of the story, which is something Nozoki Ana does very well. Oppressive tones work best when they're contrasted with things like joy, but the characters seem to turn to squabbling or depression when they should be happy.

Ultimately, I feel let down by this story's failure to fully explore it's themes. I actually expected the story to eventually be about how a polyamorous relationship could work - the idea is even brought up by a side character early in the story. .



For a dark and sobering story about romance and adult life, I give this story a 6, with points taken off for failing to contrast tones and for a sudden and unfulfilling ending.

... Last updated on January 8th, 2017, 12:49am

I'm really happy that so many people like it, not that I'm that suprised. It deserves bigger attention than it gets really. Also,we in Hanashi will finish it no matter what! Might take some time but it will be completed!

Although there are only 8 chaps so far, I was impressed with the quality of this manga, both translation and art.Mild sex scenes. 10/10 and I am so looking forward to the next chaps

i was so sure i put up a review for this one. The author's plot and storyline, character development surprised me a little because i could relate very well to what her characters were feeling. Just today hanashi finally released more chapters for this manga and after reading through them, I am more than convinced that Ninomiya Hikaru is without a doubt a master story teller. She managed to capture the subtle details of what makes life, relationships unique and special amongst two individuals or at least that is the way i feel. It is a must read for mature audiences.

This is a story of three adults who are all psychologically "broken", finding that other two fill their own shortcomings in some way. If you want a light, predictable romance or smut, or just general romantic stuff, this is the wrong choice. If you want something with significant amount of adult themes (in terms of psychology), this is a great choice.

The downside is, if you're not a grown up, you'll likely not understand what you're missing. This manga more or less requires a certain understanding and experience in life to truly enjoy.

The plot progresses smoothly, and the characters are realistic. The drama isn't "dramatized" and touches base on a more realistic level, leaving a deeper impact on me. After each chapter I'm ready for more, without that slight hesitation that I often get with other mangas, due to the weak sub plots, or lingering progression.

I want more!!

10/10

Not the prettiest manga, but the plot more than makes up for it. I love the characters. However, it is a bit more cryptic than it needs to be (Confusing and incomplete hints add to frustration just as much as to suspense). Non the less, each chapter leaves me wanting more.

the first point i like about this manga is the art. i really like the way the eyes are drawn somehow, and the expressions of the characters. the lines are also clear and the whole of it is straightforward. the art is really a big plus for me.

i also like all the characters. i usually hate inconsiderate people like youko, but the author manage to pull it off making her look 'cute'. the 'meek' girl is also usually annoying, but here she is very like-able and serene. the moody and angsty main character is also not my usual cup of tea, but here in this manga he just work. and the combination of the characters also work, and you will not feel it is unbelievable for such different people able to be friends and friends-with-benefits.

the plot progression is logical and the ending is one of the best ending out there. i appreciate that no one will be left hanging. i always prefer the tenchi solution in my harems.

and the best part of this manga to me is the musings of the characters, their philosophical take on the situation, and their analysis of their emotions. it make their whole character become more real and developed and more like-able.

a great read.

Great romantic set-up that makes living with 2 babes seem realistic ^ ^

Good drawings, good manga!