I'd like to start off with the high points of this manga: its art. The art in this story is rich and every panel is meticulously hand-drawn.
I've seen manga packed to the brim with computer effects, but this manga couldn't be more opposite as you can tell each stroke was through a pen or nib. It's absolutely breath-taking in that regard.
Now, my greatest problem is with the story's the ending, as is with just about everyone's else issue. It's not necessarily a bad ending in the sense you might expect, but for me, it was terribly dissatisfying.
Now, I want to clarify my feelings on this, because the ending isn't out of nowhere. On the contrary, I feel like it'd been hinted out throughout the entire series. It was obvious where feelings laid on both sides of our characters, but ultimately, I had hoped things would end differently for them. I ended up being too attached to one character while at times mildly annoyed with the main character, which was what made me further dissatisfied with the ending.
It's probably this bias that leaves me with this as my review. The main character is frustrating at times with his attitude and actions. There's a bit of patience required when it comes to reading the male lead, which I think explains in part why a lot of readers are disappointed with the ending.
Also, the love triangle that forms. Hanami never grew on me much, perhaps because I saw her through Tetsuo's eyes. I don't understand why he fell in love with her, besides her face (and maybe her sunshine personality that seems to appear almost flawless). It feels like he only sees what's on the surface and not what's she's actually like as a person. He focuses so much on her supposed perfections that made it hard for me to like her because of it. Hanami seems like a nice person, given the quality traits previously mentioned, but she appears too perfect and thus too attainable for anyone to really have as a romantic partner. Hence, why she is more suited to remaining as his muse than anything else.
I guess I just really liked Akira a lot more in comparison, considering she is on of the leading characters in the story.
However, the explicit scenes were handled in a mature context and not at all like some of the other seinen manga I've read. It's not overly gratuitous in the same manner as unnecessary fanservice, and neither is it set in a dark setting where rape is commonly depicted. Nor is it gruesome or unpleasant to read in those settings. It's awkward and clumsy at times, and steamy, befitting of its romance tag without being too over the top as most shoujo fall under. It's intense at times, but it's something to be expected from a seinen manga. Overall, it was well-rounded and explored, I'd say.
But ultimately, I can't disregard the ending.
It took me a few years to touch this manga again because of it, but it's not something unreadable after it. It just leaves this bitter taste in your mouth that makes you want to rinse out that makes it hard to pick it up again after the disappointment that first sets in.