manga without screentone
14 years ago
Posts: 49
any manga that doesnt use any screentone like xxxholic? 😕

14 years ago
Posts: 2133
Blue (Ignore the shoujo-ai tag if you're not into that; there's only unrequited GL here, and no girl x girl scenes at all)
The last 3 chapters of Kiseki no Koibito

14 years ago
Posts: 20
- Dogs, Bullets and Carnage
- Shirokuro Kitan
- Are You Alice?

14 years ago
Posts: 1439
I hope that I looked up "screentone" correctly... (I apologize in advance if these actually have screentone)
Gokusen
Usagi Drop and any other work by UNITA Yumi?
work by ONO Natsume I think...
work by NAKAMURA Asumiko??

14 years ago
Posts: 2133
Quote from hobbitelf518
work by ONO Natsume I think...
work by NAKAMURA Asumiko??
Seconded! I can't believe I forgot about these two mangaka - they draw in very unique styles.
But I disagree with Are You Alice? From what I can recall, the art has a quite bit of screen-tone - though perhaps not as much as that of most manga.

14 years ago
Posts: 1439
Wait... can someone really tell me what "screentone" is? All I get on google/wiki is "alternative to hatching, etc..."
Because if it's that... "pointillism" background then... Usagi Drop fails... T_T

14 years ago
Posts: 3120

14 years ago
Posts: 197
Quote from hobbitelf518
Wait... can someone really tell me what "screentone" is? All I get on google/wiki is "alternative to hatching, etc..."
Because if it's that... "pointillism" background then... Usagi Drop fails... T_T
Well...it's, you know...shading. Like when the mangaka uses various shades of grey for drawing and colouring, apart from just black and white. The OP gave a very good example of a manga with screentone-less art; xxxHoLic. You see how the colours are either black or white, with little to no grey colouring / cross-hatching / shading etc., right? And there's no 'water-colour effect' to the art. It's all very starkly contrasting.
I love that style too, btw. So I'll be watching this topic 🙂

14 years ago
Posts: 707
What is wrong with screentone?

14 years ago
Posts: 73
@hobbitelf518 screentone is that gray-ish "shading" you see in manga, it's also used for patterns. http://screentone.deviantart.com/ will give you some example on it. Basically, anything in manga that isn't black, or white, is done with tone.
@OP
Check out other CLAMP works, maybe?
Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle might work.
If you don't mind BL, MINAZUKI Akira doesn't use much tone, if any...
Naked Ape doesn't use much screentone in their works either. They do both BL and non-BL so if you don't like BL, they have some shoujo for you.

14 years ago
Posts: 3120
Quote from cyclamen
Well...it's, you know...shading. Like when the mangaka uses various shades of grey for drawing and colouring, apart from just black and white. The OP gave a very good example of a manga with screentone-less art; xxxHoLic. You see how the colours are either black or white, with little to no grey colouring / cross-hatching / shading etc., right? And there's no 'water-colour effect' to the art. It's all very starkly contrasting.
I love that style too, btw. So I'll be watching this topic 🙂
Screentone is a type of shading, not shading itself.

14 years ago
Posts: 1439
Oh okay (I think...)! Then... UNITA Yumi useless the less than manga norm for screentone. 😀 (I remembered thinking: zomg... the contrast is crazy at some points in Sukimasuki)
Thanks @cyclamen and @miko amayo for the definition/explanation of screentone! Yay! Something new I learned today!! 😃

14 years ago
Posts: 1000
14 years ago
Posts: 49
ahhh thanks for the suggestions!! so many! I`ll check one by one 😲