bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
If you're reading an original story by a Japanese author but it's online-only and formatted in a vertical strip with full color, what do you call it?
Manga
Webcomic
Webtoon
Other
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

Manga to redraw (for those who mind the art)!!

Pages (4[ 1 2 3 4 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 64

I don't know. I'm one of those people that appreciates seeing the evolution of the artist.

If I had to pick though, these could all benefit from a face lift in certain parts:
Ah! Megami-Sama
Beck
Cheeky Angel
Flame of Recca
Nodame Cantabile

On the otherhand, I've actually seen some series where I think the art has gotten worse as it progressed, namely:
Fruits Basket
Kare Kano
I preferred how these series looked early in the series compared to later chapters. Maybe it's just me, maybe I'm weird. shrug °v(.)v°


user avatar
Patent Pending
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 520

Skip Beat!
Perfect Girl Evolution
Angel Densetsu
Ghost Hunt
Trinity Blood
Hellsing


________________
Post #144685 - Reply To (#144618) by gothung
Post #144685 - Reply To (#144618) by gothung
user avatar
Mad With a Hat
Moderator


17 years ago
Posts: 4764

Quote from gothung

On the otherhand, I've actually seen some series where I think the art has gotten worse as it progressed, namely:
Fruits Basket
Kare Kano
I preferred how these series looked early in the series compared to later chapters. Maybe it's just me, maybe I'm weird. shrug °v(.)v°

Really? Fruits Basket??
It didn't look to good when it only began, but after the manga progressed in the later volumes, it looked much better..


________________

Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
[img]http://i411.photobucket.com/albums/pp199/SyberAngelGabrielle/couplesig.jpg[/img]
[color=black]And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
[/color]

Click 'n Play!

If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.

user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 4030

Parts of Hunter X Hunter >.<

Art styles usually grow on me.


Post #144707 - Reply To (#144496) by lynzajw
Post #144707 - Reply To (#144496) by lynzajw
user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 2342

Quote from lynzajw

Skip Beat! and Tokyo Crazy Paradise - great series, art that makes me queasy. Anything by her, actually, I really just hate the way she draws.

I second that.


Post #144913 - Reply To (#144509) by NightSwan
Post #144913 - Reply To (#144509) by NightSwan
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 75

Quote from NightSwan

I second claymore and hellsing.
If the art had been better, I could have brought myselft to read more of claymore.. Although I don't like it anyway..

Hellsing really does have a strange start..

It comes from the fact it was a hentai story on the very beginning... You still can find it on some Mirc server . It's quite rare . It's about the rape of seras by the valentine brothers and Alucard save her .
This is quite interesting to see how much it evolved :for instance some of the attributes of Anderson belongs to Alucard in this draft like the glove with the quote of the Bible

So Hellsing has inherited the plot and the drawing of this oneshot : basically the mangaka had not really any ideas about where he was going hence this very awkard beginning .
As I said before I think the anime beginning is awesome and should be the canon one :
the realisation is way more elegant (dizzy travelling for the first meeting between seras and alucard , bloody and surreal light , moon rising as Alucard gathers his powers in something reminiscent of Sin city ,alucard shooting blindly , reloading his gun with his canins , telepathy between seras and alucard through the eyes ,etc...)
and it conveys more thing about the vampire universe (like the choice explicitly offered to seras this time ,his real liking in her , the despise of alucard toward most of the others vampires , the telepathy of alucard , the seduction through the power of the vampire priest and the kiss/bite scene of alucard , the insane level of strenght of alucard as he's really enjoying the situation by mocking the other vampire to a extent rarely matched : "you're a fool that creates slave to do his dirty work , a coward and an incompetent incapable of doing anything on your own : you're not worthy of the lowest pit of hell!!! " 😲


Post #144931 - Reply To (#144618) by gothung
Post #144931 - Reply To (#144618) by gothung
user avatar
Werd Nerd
icon Member


17 years ago
Posts: 590

Quote from gothung

On the otherhand, I've actually seen some series where I think the art has gotten worse as it progressed, namely:
Fruits Basket
Kare Kano
I preferred how these series looked early in the series compared to later chapters. Maybe it's just me, maybe I'm weird. shrug °v(.)v°

True, true, I agree in some ways. Hana-Kimi's like that...not that I was in love with the art in the beginning or anything, but I really didn't like the way it changed towards the end. Besides which, eyebrows do NOT cover half of someone's face. They just don't.


________________

poof "SHOUJOMAN IS HERE!"
Just Lynz, drop the -ajw

Post #145093 - Reply To (#144913) by ghinzdra
Post #145093 - Reply To (#144913) by ghinzdra
user avatar
Mad With a Hat
Moderator


17 years ago
Posts: 4764

Quote from ghinzdra

Quote from NightSwan

I second claymore and hellsing.
If the art had been better, I could have brought myselft to read more of claymore.. Although I don't like it anyway..

Hellsing really does have a strange start..

It comes from the fact it was a hentai story on the very beginning... You still can find it on some Mirc server . It's quite rare . It's about the rape of seras by the valentine brothers and Alucard save her .
This is quite interesting to see how much it evolved :for instance some of the attributes of Anderson belongs to Alucard in this draft like the glove with the quote of the Bible

So Hellsing has inherited the plot and the drawing of this oneshot : basically the mangaka had not really any ideas about where he was going hence this very awkard beginning .
As I said before I think the anime beginning is awesome and should be the canon one :
the realisation is way more elegant (dizzy travelling for the first meeting between seras and alucard , bloody and surreal light , moon rising as Alucard gathers his powers in something reminiscent of Sin city ,alucard shooting blindly , reloading his gun with his canins , telepathy between seras and alucard through the eyes ,etc...)
and it conveys more thing about the vampire universe (like the choice explicitly offered to seras this time ,his real liking in her , the despise of alucard toward most of the others vampires , the telepathy of alucard , the seduction through the power of the vampire priest and the kiss/bite scene of alucard , the insane level of strenght of alucard as he's really enjoying the situation by mocking the other vampire to a extent rarely matched : "you're a fool that creates slave to do his dirty work , a coward and an incompetent incapable of doing anything on your own : you're not worthy of the lowest pit of hell!!! " 😲

Yeah.. I was reffering more to the art, since this thread is about the art...
But the about the story itself, there was comedy where it shouldn't be.. so.. I don't know..


________________

Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
[img]http://i411.photobucket.com/albums/pp199/SyberAngelGabrielle/couplesig.jpg[/img]
[color=black]And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
[/color]

Click 'n Play!

If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.

user avatar
Artist Alchemist
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 562

ima go with inuyasha. i didnt like the pointed cheeks 2 much and often rounded em when i drew the characters....i always changed a lot of it....and sometimes completely changed it and making it my own creation....hmmmm and ichi the killer. their art was just weird in how they drew the people. and ichi always had the most retarded smile


________________

SWEET DESPAIR'S LUVER ^^
proud member of Heavennevaeh's evil army.
http://www.freeshoutbox.net/sromu&hl=1&PHPSESSID=fb5svuvafp3dd699l3l5mg2h74
I love Alex ^
^ The Rev.R.I.P.

Member


17 years ago
Posts: 64

Quote from NightSwan

Really? Fruits Basket??

I knew it. Maybe I am weird... eh, it's not a surprise.

Quote from lynzajw

Hana-Kimi's like that...not that I was in love with the art in the beginning or anything, but I really didn't like the way it changed towards the end.

Yeah, I forgot about Hana-Kimi. It's like the mangaka are starting to draw their characters in a way that's easier for them (faster to get chapters out to feed the fans) but they sacrifice appearances in exchange.

The eternal debate: appearance or deadline? Of course the deadline wins.


user avatar
Pharmakeus
icon Member


17 years ago
Posts: 417

Angel Densetsu ... Actually; just the mangaka's works (e.g. Claymore)
Though it probably fits the story... I also agree; One Piece - I just can't stand to read too much of it...
Superior,
The earlier volumes of Bleach - I guess I've developed a like for smoother more modern art...

hmm... seems I am just repeating other's suggestions. Ah, should probably post earlier...


________________

Can you imagine an imaginary menagerie manager imagining managing an imaginary menagerie?

user avatar
Smooth Operator
Super Mod


17 years ago
Posts: 5329

GTO for sure.

Golden Boy.

Beck. I would make it even more awesome(is that even possible?)


________________
user avatar
Member


17 years ago
Posts: 2581

Warn: Banned

________________

Glados is a bitch. She made me kill the companion cube, the only friend I'll ever have. 😢

Chibidoro-sama=Neko-freak

user avatar
Smooth Operator
Super Mod


17 years ago
Posts: 5329

kinda.

edit: but I love the art in Beck, I would just redraw it to make it more realistic.


________________
Post #147599 - Reply To (#147596) by xombiemonkey
Post #147599 - Reply To (#147596) by xombiemonkey
user avatar
Mad With a Hat
Moderator


17 years ago
Posts: 4764

Quote from xombiemonkey

Isn't this kinda similar?

Really?.. Maybe... But here you don't have to state how bad the art was in general.. Just that you would like to see it better...

Quote from hubris

Angel Densetsu ... Actually; just the mangaka's works (e.g. Claymore)
Though it probably fits the story... I also agree; One Piece - I just can't stand to read too much of it...
Superior,
The earlier volumes of Bleach - I guess I've developed a like for smoother more modern art...

hmm... seems I am just repeating other's suggestions. Ah, should probably post earlier...

No, that's fine^^
I'm thinking of counting the votes anyway, so there is no linitation.


________________

Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
[img]http://i411.photobucket.com/albums/pp199/SyberAngelGabrielle/couplesig.jpg[/img]
[color=black]And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
[/color]

Click 'n Play!

If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.

Pages (4[ 1 2 3 4 ] Next
You must be registered to post!