Melo Holic

This manhwa is really amazing in its own way, and I love the drama in it so much
And I agree completely with moonmystery with how I end up podering about it~ also since I don't usually read tags I was shocked as well xD

... Last updated 8 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

Good, but not amazing

by cherrykookie
11 years ago

Rating: 7.0 / 10.0

People rave about this, but I don't find it especially amazing.. rather on the average side.

PROS:

Has some good suspense moments
A few good twists

CONS:

Romance was too fast.. I didn't feel anything for the main couple.
Characters weren't all that likeable.. I wasn't fond of any of the characters. The gym teacher was alright though.
Turns more and more cliche, especially the ending. Very unsatisfying imo... It was also quite predictable.
Average art

Overall, the cons outweigh the pros, and it was disappointing given all the rave. It's an alright manhwa, just not amazing unless you're 100% new to the mystery/psychological genre.

... Last updated 11 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

Not a typical romance manhwa

by bull3thole
12 years ago

Rating: 8.0 / 10.0

The romance as a whole was good and I really liked the supernatural element added to the manhwa. The relationship started out like another typically romance but after chapter 56 things started to down hill for me.

The psychological element after chapter 56 was really a turn off for me because the plot just got even more cliche. I felt that the manhwa could have been better but after so and so happened I just felt that the manhwa was a real letdown since it had potential. The comedy was funny for maybe about the first half and then it started to be repetitive.

Overall he manhwa is different but not much that will make me rate this manhwa above a 8.5/10. I still recommend people to read this manhwa though since some people will like the twist and some like me who don't like it.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Blah, why bring in the psychology

by FormX
13 years ago

Rating: N/A

Beginning was certainly impressive, I can give you that.
It went down a bit after it brought in the stalker thing, but okay, be cliche if you want to.

Then in the end the DID was used as an explanation, and that just failed for me. Not sure why, but I guess it has to do with actually studying it in psychology.

So while the end may be a masterpiece or what not for other people, I didn't buy it.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Eh, so so

by sailorliones
13 years ago

Rating: N/A

I didn't like the beginning. Frankly, this was in my do not read pile. However, I read a few comments on it, and thought to give it a try. The beginning was still horridly boring. However, I am now writing this after having finished it and not realizing where the time went. I've been ravenously hungry for 2 hrs and forgot to eat. Darn it. Good read, though not an amazing piece of work. No tears were shed here. It's very engrossing though.

Was this comment useful? Yes

HOLY SHIT.....JUST FREAKIN READ IT

by mystichead
13 years ago

Rating: 9.1 / 10.0

I have no other words to better describe this manga......it doesnt belong in any genre but yet it belongs in many at once.....silly to serious to serious.........Twists and mind fucks (the awesome type)....

JUST READ IT...... and have urself blown away

Was this comment useful? Yes

Lost for words

by giinko
13 years ago

Rating: 8.2 / 10.0

".................."
After finishing the webcomic, my first thought was: "............", then "I don't believe this, I've pulled another all-nighter for reading again!" And it is worth every time. Like all the previous comments, this web comic is crazy, is fascinating, is twisting surprisingly awesome. It's one of the kind!

For those who love psychological thriller, romantic love, roller-coaster drama, this is definitely a must read. The art is great and I really like the way the authors + artists ended each chapter. Even though I guessed the out come of the story pretty much half way through, but this story will surely pulled you in its wheel.

... Last updated 4 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

unique love story

by wildpenguin17
13 years ago

Rating: 9.0 / 10.0

This was a great melodrama and i really like view of love in the story..the original pessimistic and optimistic view.. Even though the supernatural power thing and this kind of love can only exist in literature, the love was really convincing. Blending of reality and dreams...its a theme.

It had amazing suspense and it didn't feel ridiculous at any point!

I liked the format of the story too and reading a manwha from the male protagonist's point of view was refreshing.

Secret Garden, the live melodrama came into my mind when I read the last chapter.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Wow

by Anabiotic_Pineapple
13 years ago

Rating: 8.5 / 10.0

All I can say is wow. Coming into this, I didn't expect what happened to happen. I wouldn't say this is the best romantic comedy in the world, but it certainly was very good at keeping up the suspense and then sucker punching you right when you think you have things figured out. I'd certainly recommend reading this.

Was this comment useful? Yes

We repeat

by addnine
14 years ago

Rating: 10.0 / 10.0

Yeah, don't read the spoilers! This webcomic builds up a lot of suspense and story development from the first 50 chapters and then suddenly gave me a big mindfuck. You'll be really dissapointed if you read the spoilers.

It's very good and I love the main character and the main girl character. Can't wait for the last couple chapters to be translated!

Was this comment useful? Yes

Pages (5) [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]