Art: 10
Plot: 9.5
Ending: 10
Lack of cliche: 8
Romance: 10
Characters: 9 (extra point for bishounen <3)
First thing: I LOVE the art! I love the eyes, the detail, the expressions...they were absolutely gorgeous, IMO.
The plot was seriously amazing. It was a bit hard to get into it at first (I was so confused!), but once you got over the first few chapters, everything slowly starts making sense. And I love the idea of Heaven and Hell. And there's lots of humor, too! Especially when it's randomly in the middle of an big scene, it actually made me laugh out loud. ^^ The only thing that bothered me was how you could kind of guess what was going to happen next in some parts...or why it was happening.
Ending was absolutely perfect, no worries there.
There were a few cliches, but you get over it quickly, so it's not really that big of a deal.
Romance was PERFECT. Not too little, and not too overboard, either.
And the characters...while the main character was not really that developed, I loved her strong personality and how funny she is when she's acting all dumb. XD And there are LOTS of gorgeous guys. ___ Bishounen love!
Negative side: Although it tries to be emotional, it's not really that affecting. But I thought the plot was more important in this manga (actually, I think that in all of them XD oh well!).
If you're the type to like shoujo mangas with a little fantasy, humor, and romance, and a fantastic ending, this one's for you. ^^