bannerBaka-UpdatesManga
Manga Poll
Do you prefer reading a completed or ongoing series?
I only read completed series
I prefer reading completed series but dabble in ongoing series
I don't care
I prefer reading ongoing series but dabble in completed series
I only read ongoing series
 
mascot
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

RSS Feed

Non-romantic pair

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 94

Here's something I bet no one has requested. Is it even possible for a mangaka to write a male-female pair without having some obligatory romance plot forced on us?


user avatar
Mishy
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 1737

So far I haven't read a Shoujo manga that doesn't have a non-romantic pair given that the pair is the focus of the story. This has a higher rate of occurring in other genres, especially shounen.


________________

Nulla in mundo pax sincera
"Always go too far, because that's where you'll find the truth." - Albert Camus

Post #461146 - Reply To (#461139) by Wererat42
Post #461146 - Reply To (#461139) by Wererat42
user avatar
Just passing by
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 197

Quote from Wererat42

Here's something I bet no one has requested. Is it even possible for a mangaka to write a male-female pair without having some obligatory romance plot forced on us?

Probably not. Sigh...so sad! I mean, I have no interest in romance (yet) so I don't know - but is it really impossible for a guy and girl to be a team and not fall for each other? It should be possible, right?
I reckon the only way you can expect that to happen in a work of fiction is if the the two MCs are brother and sister. (And even then, incest themes are often implied - though it's usually not canon)

This has a higher rate of occurring in other genres, especially shounen.

Nah, not really. I've read plenty of shounen / seinen and even in those, if the two protagonists are of opposite genders it will surely be implied that they're romantically interested in each other. At least towards the end, they show definite signs of ending up together. The love story is not in your face like in shoujo / josei, but it's still very 'there'.

This is because everyone (except a select few people like me) wants romance. I mean, the number of comments I've read that go "If this had some romance, it would be a hit! And my rating would've been higher" are uncountable. Mangaka have to do whatever they can to get good sales, after all.

As for recs; I have high hopes for Liar Game and Reinouryokusha Odagiri Kyouko no Uso so far, but I'm not counting on it. It's best not to get your hopes up about that kind of thing 😉


... Last edited by cyclamen 14 years ago
user avatar
ManBearPig
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 572

The only shoujo I could think of is Gold rush 21

The main female lead works as a 'male host', she used to have a relationship with a woman. The main male lead has only one-sided crush on her. The manga still focuses on their relationship as friends.


________________
Post #461162 - Reply To (#461139) by Wererat42
Post #461162 - Reply To (#461139) by Wererat42
user avatar
the mu...
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 1050

Quote from Wererat42

Here's something I bet no one has requested.

i'm pretty sure we have this type of request b4.. if i'm not mistaken tartufo ask this once... (she got a lot of request thread) 😐


user avatar
Lone Wanderer
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 2133

Oh yes - Gold Rush 21 is a good one. And it's not the male MC who has a crush on the female protagonist; it's a side character. As far as I could see, the male and female leads are just friends, with no unrequited love towards each other on either side.

Paranoia Street would probably work too - but only because everyone in that story is insane...

Goth is a 'maybe'; their relationship is open to interpretation and it was never quite made clear whether they were in love with each other or not. The male lead is bit too weird for anyone to expect a standard romance plot, anyway.

Definitely Yumekui Kenbun and perhaps Rozen Maiden (but in the case of the latter it depends on who you consider to be the female lead).

Sumire 16 Sai!! and Sumire 17 Sai!! also fit, if you can get past the protagonist's very odd personality.

This request was made before (but in a slightly different way) by unusuallove.


user avatar
Member


14 years ago
Posts: 95

You must be registered to post!