To begin with. I think Honoka Sakurai is a MUCH better example of what a shy girl should be compared to Toujo Aya. (((( SPOILER FOR ICHIGO 100))))
The fact the Aya NEVER did anything to have a happy ending with Manaka was for me, the one reason she did not deserve to have it
Sakurai, even as a shy person, fights for herself and her love, very interesting character.
Manaka was gay.... Akitsuki is kinda dumb and inexperienced, but certainly has some attitude. Thus, manaka should be more like Akitsuki in many ways.
Boths mangas had what the other lacked. For instance, in Ichigo 100, the characters would sometimes avoid taking obvious decisions for no reason other than the author wanting to restrain the development of the story. In this one, things would happen. The character wanna kiss, they kiss, they wanna start going out, they do, wanna break up, break up. I mean, they actually acted upon the situation like any of us would and then suffer the consequences, which made sense and gave a feeling of realism to the manga, and because of that, it developed in ways Ichigo 100 failed at.
the end shows that clearly with the sex and pregnancy experience
I wouldnt say this is a love polygon.
There are different romance plots going on, as it tells the life of a student, but there isnt much of a competition. The story pretty much has a main romance which it focuses upon.
it felt draggy at times. Sometimes it felt there were too many chapters for too little experience. Ichigo 100 felt like a much longer story even though they had pretty much the same ammount of chapters. The one part this manga excelled at this was at the end hough. I felt the latest chapters brought a LOT of content and meaning to the story. On that matter, ichigo 100 had much more of a Roller Coaster effect than this one. This was much more linear.
Also, something I dont usually see. Others mangas (ichigo 100 por example) only show the drama. Once the issue at hand is solved, it ends leaving the rest to your imagination. In this one, the story extended long enough to give the reader a sense of closure, it gives us a nice prologue and I think thats AWESOME! It sucks when you spend 170 chapters readring waiting to see how happy the couple you are cheering for a gonna end up, and then as soon as they get together the story ends.