Melo Holic

so many people saying it's a great twist but i dont find so.. may be because i have read the same kinds that i can find out what happens later in ths comic.. another manhwas/mangas like Cheese in the Trap, Monsters, Pandora hearts etc still have better plot twist from this (really unexpectable).
but i cant say this manhwa is bad, it's a good one, above average but not that great. 7 out of 10 from because i both the art and plot are good enough (unlike those cheesy mangas/manhwas which i cant say the titles in here)

Was this comment useful? Yes

Something...

by fisukisuki
12 years ago

Rating: 9.5 / 10.0

...so Insane, Crazy, Twisted, EVER!

But this is DEFINITELY GREAT MANHWA with Romance, Drama, Mystery, Psychological, Tragedy, Slice of life!
It's scary Manhwa! Not have Horror genre, but definitely HORROR! Scary! And Not Normal! Abnormal!
But the good thing is, the ending is acceptable! WORTH! As long as you not scared at unexpected picture or close to surprise thing. 😀

Was this comment useful? Yes

Not a typical romance manhwa

by bull3thole
12 years ago

Rating: 8.0 / 10.0

The romance as a whole was good and I really liked the supernatural element added to the manhwa. The relationship started out like another typically romance but after chapter 56 things started to down hill for me.

The psychological element after chapter 56 was really a turn off for me because the plot just got even more cliche. I felt that the manhwa could have been better but after so and so happened I just felt that the manhwa was a real letdown since it had potential. The comedy was funny for maybe about the first half and then it started to be repetitive.

Overall he manhwa is different but not much that will make me rate this manhwa above a 8.5/10. I still recommend people to read this manhwa though since some people will like the twist and some like me who don't like it.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Deceiving

by sculamio
12 years ago

Rating: 8.0 / 10.0

Warning: This webcomic is not what it appears to be. It is both a horror story and a love story.

To be honest, I felt like I had been tricked by the authors. The story wasn't at all what I was expecting, and a lot of potential was given up for the plot twists and freaky nature of some of the characters. There was so much drama that it pretty much broke through my willing suspension of belief. The psychological aspect was also handled fairly unrealistically. It was disappointing, but the ending kind of makes up for it (at least the main character managed to stay consistent). Despite all its flaws, the story was still fairly engrossing (hey, I read all the way to the end), so I'd recommend it if you like mysterious, twisty horror/love stories. xD

In TV Tropes terms, this whole story is a case of What the Heck, Heroine?

... Last updated 12 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

Beautiful

by ListeningDaisy
13 years ago

Rating: 9.0 / 10.0

It starts out sweet, then descends into a twisting turning plot that will draw you in and make you read it until the end. It is simply a perfect example of an amazing webcomic. As some below me have said though, DO NOT READ SPOILERS, this is an amazing story and reading spoilers would take some of the fun out of reading it.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Blah, why bring in the psychology

by FormX
13 years ago

Rating: N/A

Beginning was certainly impressive, I can give you that.
It went down a bit after it brought in the stalker thing, but okay, be cliche if you want to.

Then in the end the DID was used as an explanation, and that just failed for me. Not sure why, but I guess it has to do with actually studying it in psychology.

So while the end may be a masterpiece or what not for other people, I didn't buy it.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Eh, so so

by sailorliones
13 years ago

Rating: N/A

I didn't like the beginning. Frankly, this was in my do not read pile. However, I read a few comments on it, and thought to give it a try. The beginning was still horridly boring. However, I am now writing this after having finished it and not realizing where the time went. I've been ravenously hungry for 2 hrs and forgot to eat. Darn it. Good read, though not an amazing piece of work. No tears were shed here. It's very engrossing though.

Was this comment useful? Yes

by duaardo
13 years ago

Rating: 10.0 / 10.0

I really do not know how to express the feeling I had when i read the last chapter of this manhwa. It was something so great, so tense... Really, you should read it and enjoy it. There are few manga/manhwas that may give you chills and even make you shed a manly tear. I meant it!

... Last updated 13 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

AMAZING

by whitespade
13 years ago

Rating: 9.8 / 10.0

i finish this in less than 6hours. this reminds me of harry potter where i absolutely felt the need to finish from cover to cover non stop, that's how engrossing it is. i cannot believe people followed this week to week, it must be especially painful to them!

first my heart thump from the sweetness of the romance, then my heart beat faster for the thrill of danger, then my heart nearly burst with the unexpected revelation! i cannot say more of it will ruin the experience, but really read this if you are a fan of original story.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Unexpectedly beautiful.

by AliceinAmestris
13 years ago

Rating: N/A

I've always lived the artstyle or webcomics do naturally I loved this art. The story was unpredictable with plot twists everywhere. It was very gripping, I couldn't put it down. I lived the ending. It somehow seemed very bitter sweet but appropriate.

Was this comment useful? Yes

Pages (5) [ 1 2 3 4 5 ]