manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
How big of a manga fan are you (in terms of # of series read / reading)?
Beginner (<10)
Casual reader (10-100)
Rookie (100-250)
Intermediate amateur (250-500)
Amateur (500-750)
Advanced amateur (750-1k)
Intermediate professional (1-1.5k)
Professional (1.5k-2k)
Advanced professional (2k-3k)
Sensei (3k+)
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

A manga, novel or movie featuring a real love polygon

Back to I'm Looking For...


You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
cyclamen
Post #462877
user avatar
Just passing by
Member

3:53 pm, Apr 20 2011
Posts: 190


You know what I mean, right? Most of these so-called 'love triangles' are actually pretty ordinary affairs with a romantic rival who just doesn't know when to give up.
A loves B, B loves A...and C, for some inexplicable reason, seems to think s/he has a chance with A (or B), and...well...we all know how it plays out from there onwards roll

Well, I dislike that kind of thing. So I'd like to ask for a novel, manga, movie or anime (no TV series, please!) with an actual love polygon. As in;

A --> B --> C --> A (A loves B, who's in love with C, who in turn loves A)

The number of people involved has to be three or more, of course. And they really, genuinely, have to be romantically interested in each other in the way I've indicated. Please no 'shocking revelations' such as a 'C' type character who eventually goes "I thought I loved A, but it's really B I wanted all along!" <_<

As for the conclusion, it can be;
1. One (or all) of them finding someone outside of their polygon to love

2.The polygon remaining unresolved (I'd really prefer this option, but I guess it's a bit too much to hope for!)

3. A & B realizing that things are hopeless and deciding to get together despite B still holding a torch for C, and C bowing out and going off to find him/herself someone else, while still being in love with A.

...or any other suitable way. But the polygon should not turn back into an ordinary one at any point!
Cantarella is a perfect example for a story that at first glance looks like it'll fit my request (as in Cesare --> Chiaro --> Lucrezia --> Cesare), but which eventually falls back into the typical triangle mode when
Spoiler (highlight to view)
Lucrezia and Chiaro end up together

Cardcaptor Sakura also follows that path.


Also, I am NOT looking for harem or reverse harem manga! In fact, the very concept of a harem completely contradicts my request.
Any other genre except hentai, smut, ecchi, yaoi, shota/lolicon is welcome (shounen-ai, shoujo-ai and yuri are fine)
Gender-bender is acceptable only if the people involved are well aware of each other's genders before they fall in love (So please don't rec those "OMG! I thought I was gay but I'm sooo glad I'm not!" manga)

I know this is a tricky request, but thank you for reading and (hopefully) replying! smile

________________
User Posted Image
Sagaris
Post #462879
user avatar
Member

3:57 pm, Apr 20 2011
Posts: 3116


Apparently that's the point of Wa! (KOJIMA Akira)

Ziggy
Post #462923
Member

7:48 pm, Apr 20 2011
Posts: 236


Hatsukoi Limited

calstine
Post #463054 - Reply to (#462923) by Ziggy
user avatar
Lone Wanderer
Member

5:15 am, Apr 21 2011
Posts: 1303


Quote from Ziggy


She said she didn't want ecchi.

This is a really interesting idea. Pity I can't think of a single thing that suits your requirements (but that might just be because I don't read a lot of romance manga)

________________
User Posted Image
boatswain
Post #463170
Member

6:16 pm, Apr 21 2011
Posts: 28


The only manga I can think of atm is They, Too, Love but the focus of it is not so much the love polygon but rather their lives as incredibly individual, quirky people. It's an excellent read nonetheless, even if the ending is a bit wanting.

Brucie_kun
Post #463194
user avatar
ManBearPig
Member

7:58 pm, Apr 21 2011
Posts: 570


Pretty much the romance plot in Princess

Leo loves Eschilde loves Biyon loves Bii
Sei and Skadei have a crush on Bii.
Lala and her sister love Skadei.

________________
User Posted Image
Rape is imminent.
cyclamen
Post #463414
user avatar
Just passing by
Member

4:12 pm, Apr 22 2011
Posts: 190


Thank you for the replies! I'll check out everything (Except Hatsukoi. I dislike ecchi manga)

More is always a plus!

________________
User Posted Image
cyclamen
Post #466317
user avatar
Just passing by
Member

10:17 am, May 4 2011
Posts: 190


Bump!

________________
User Posted Image
akari_mizunashi
Post #466449
user avatar
Member

10:37 pm, May 4 2011
Posts: 1000


Camera Camera Camera
The main character loves his stepbrother and is being pursued by a photographer guy. His stepbrother is being pursued by a girl but is in love with another girl, who in turn likes someone else. This photographer guy is being pursued by this shota trap, for whom he has no feelings. Then all of a sudden the photographer isn't really into the main character any more, and like, totally isn't gay, why would you even think that, even though the main character is after him now. And then a woman from his past resurfaces, and they still have feelings for each other, even though she's married. And then... well, the main character and the photographer have lovely sparkle relations and it leaves marks and whatever but then
Spoiler (highlight to view)
the photographer 23-skidoos to Europe and never comes back, the shota ungays himself and marries an Italian woman, the stepbrother gets married to the girl who was chasing him and then gets super fat, and the main character turns into a pedophile and sometimes hits on his stepbrother's kid.

I don't know if that fits your criteria or not but it sure did take enough time to type out.

unusuallove
Post #466453
Member

11:22 pm, May 4 2011
Posts: 710


Parfait Tic

A and C are guys, B is a girl
First: A loves B who loves C who doesn't love B
Then: A loves B and B loves A but shit goes down, and that gets screwed up so
then: B loves A and C loves B but A doesn't love B
then: A loves B who again loves C

et cetera et cetera. It's really convoluted, but if you're looking for a real love triangle where the protagonist is in love with both people at some point, look no further.

Other mangas you could try (for all of these I didn't know who the main character would end up with):

Vampire Knight
A loves B and C loves B and B loves both A and C

Billion Princess
A loves B who loves C who loves/loved D (not so much this one though)

Nana
A loves B and B loves C so
A loves D and D is an asshole so
A loves E but then shit goes down smile and
A loves D and E and E and D both love A

Meanwhile:
F loves D and D loves F but probably only as a friend or sister so
F loves G who also loves F
F loved H but H loves J who also loves H and is best friends with A
Oh, also K loves J and J might love K

Anyway, there's no easy answer for any of them when it comes to their love issues . . .

Kashimashi - Girl Meets Girl

A and C are girls, B's a guy
A loves B who loves C
B gets turned into a girl
C loves B, who doesn't know what to think
A thinks she loves B, but she's also confused

This one is kind of bizarre

Anyway, I hope this helped some.

cyclamen
Post #467078
user avatar
Just passing by
Member

7:24 am, May 7 2011
Posts: 190


Umm...thanks for Camera, but it sounds so silly that I won't be reading it. But your long description is much appreciated, akari_mizunashi, because it was a good and timely warning LOL

@unusuallove - Thank you for the recs! I'll be checking them all out except VK and Nana, which annoy me for some odd reason...

________________
User Posted Image
cyclamen
Post #476680
user avatar
Just passing by
Member

4:08 pm, Jun 16 2011
Posts: 190


Bump!

________________
User Posted Image
You must be registered to post!

Back to I'm Looking For...  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer