banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

any manga/manhwa/manhua/oel/artbook/doujinshi/novel/" drama cd" you consider as wrong?

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
hiiiithere
Member

12:55 am, Dec 7 2013
Posts: 98


I am asking a stupid question(maybe).I think everything in manga updates can be read and it is absolutely correct to read them.Everything refers to manga,manhwa,manhua,doujinshi,oel,artbook,novel,"drama cd".
I consider only "hentai without borderline h" to be wrong to read.
All the above discussion is for adults.I am not searching material for children.
What do you think about my idea?
also what material in manga updates do you consider to be wrong?
I consider only "hentai without borderline h" to be wrongi.e.I say"i will read all materials in mu except"hentai without borderline h" and it is absolutely correct to do so.
What do you think?

user avatar
Me too ♥
Member

12:43 pm, Dec 7 2013
Posts: 1139


I wouldn't call anything wrong.
I'll read anything even things others may consider sick or inappropriate or I guess in this case "wrong"
Now when it comes to something I won't read ... I guess the closest thing would be a romance with an older female and younger male, especially if it's incest related ... wait only if it's incest related. However I wouldn't consider it wrong, more a tag I would rather ignore.

Quote from godlover
I consider only "hentai without borderline h" to be wrongi.e.I say"i will read all materials in mu except"hentai without borderline h" and it is absolutely correct to do so.
In other words hentai ...
OK it's absolutely correct for you to do so, but not for me.

________________
Yes yes, I know I make longwinded comments, but that's just me >.<
I should proof read my comments more, but I won't...
So keep in mind I'm filled with typos

Check out FAQ and Forum Rules if you haven't yet.
For errors linking in threads
user avatar
Member

3:20 pm, Dec 7 2013
Posts: 23


I don't really get, what your itention is. What dou you mean with "wrong". Wrong like two middle aged men bathing together in salad dressing and putting each other a finger in the butt and sucking their big toes, while singing the french national anthem and watching sex and the city? Or wrong like 1+1=3?
Well, whatever. I consider cencored Hentai wrong. Something like a blank, where should be a beautiful vagina. Because the reason I read Hentai is because I want to see what happens.
Well, sure, there are some disgusting (from my POV) things, I would although consider wrong, like Guro, giving birth and whatever, or shota, because I hate it when those stupid brats are pleassured with beautiful Onee-sans or Okaa-sans, if you know what I mean.
However, as I said. I don't get your question.

________________
User Posted Image
Post #624560
user avatar
Procrastinator and
Member

10:58 am, Dec 14 2013
Posts: 1025


Hentai without borderline H... so, Hentai?

Anyway, I actually don't consider anything wrong. I respect those who like to read shota, guro etc etc, only of course if it is limited to reading it and not practicing it (that would be a crime...). I have read shotacon, but I'm not into real little kids having sex... I do believe there is a line between "real" and "fiction" and one can like the fiction part of it, while hating the "real world issue". Another example, I can read BDSM in manga, but I avoid to the max seeing it for real. Or like males who are into traps in mangas, but don't feel attracted to it in real life.

If I were to consider the minimal details of the mangas I read, I wouldn't read many of them, probably. Some of the yaoi I read has a "attempt rape turns into love" story, some ecchi mangas have a heavy objectification of women, some shoujo turns girls into innocent babies who only live to love the opposite gender...

By that, none of them are wrong as works of fiction with a propose (ecchi with sexy girls, shoujo with innocent leads, yaoi with violent relationships), trying to sell a idea. I try to avoid most of them who bother me (right now I avoid reading anything with stockholm syndrom, rape turns into love etc), but I don't actually judge those who like reading it.

Post #624798
user avatar
Come and Go
Member

10:01 pm, Dec 15 2013
Posts: 398


Maybe some more clear example is needed. Because I certainly doesn't understand what's wrong you mean.
For me, wrong is for me to read Yaoi, while Im still a normal healthy man.
But I've read a few Yaoi manga, and it scare me.....
A LOT.
But sometimes one of the guy is looked alot like girls, so I still could try imagining its normal relation.
Wait, oh gosh... that is so WRONG.
But, then again, I also read futanari hentai manga and sometimes I wonder...
is this YAOI?
Because the futanari could pair with other futanari (they both have Mr. P) and they use the backdoor.
Does that mean they both boys but with faces of girl and big breast and miss V under Mr. P?
WRONG AGAIN.
And then, and then.... recently I got kinda hooked up with stories about guys looks like girl, gender bender, lots of Trap....
Example : Prunus Girl, No Bra, Mizuho Ambivalent
So they are not Yaoi? (I hope Im WRONG)

Post #625441 - Reply to (#624798) by Great
user avatar
hiiiithere
Member

6:17 am, Dec 21 2013
Posts: 98


Quote from Great
Maybe some more clear example is needed. Because I certainly doesn't understand what's wrong you mean.
For me, wrong is for me to read Yaoi, while Im still a normal healthy man.
But I've read a few Yaoi manga, and it scare me.....
A LOT.
But sometimes one of the guy is looked alot like girls, so I ...

I think it is wrong to read "hentai without borderline h" because it is porn.I consider porn and masturbation to be completely wrong.So,That's why I said "hentai without borderline h" is wrong.Now,are you clear? i e for me porn is morally wrong to read(according to me).

Post #625456 - Reply to (#625441) by godlover
user avatar
Member

8:27 am, Dec 21 2013
Posts: 566


I think what's confusing people is this idea of "hentai without borderline h". That genre does not exist. There's hentai and there's borderline h. It would be like saying "seinen without shounen" is a genre. What I'm guessing you're meaning is hentai.

Also, I've asked you this question before but haven't got a real answer. What exactly is your point in creating all of these threads trying to figure out exactly which manga are porn. I understand you think its morally wrong to read porn, but is it such a big deal if you accidentally read a porn manga? Can you really not tell from the description and the cover of a manga if its something you would consider to be porn?

Post #625624
user avatar
Come and Go
Member

10:16 pm, Dec 22 2013
Posts: 398


Oh. OK.
At least I understand the question.
What any "things" (any manga/manhwa/manhua/oel/artbook/doujinshi/novel/drama cd/etc) that we consider as wrong?
Maybe godlover just want to know other view point of wrong, are there anyone with the same opinion as him/her.
For me, porn/hentai is also wrong, BUT, there are still but, not all people think something is wrong and would avoid it completely.
Yeah, I know its wrong, but still I could manage to read it. dead
Even normal porn/hentai is almost nothing compared to so many other outrageous think out there. roll eyes
I still feel porn/hentai is wrong, but I also think its only fiction. The byproduct of some imagination.
For other case, maybe there are people that think magic is wrong, and then they dislike "Harry Potter". bigrazz

user avatar
Member

9:39 am, Dec 23 2013
Posts: 566


i can understand wanting to know others point of view. although, i think a more interesting topic would be why do you consider a particular type of manga to be wrong. but i think that might already be a separate thread.

but it just seems that whenever godlover doesn't get the exact answer their looking for, they just start a new thread in a different forum that is almost the same question. That is getting pretty annoying.

Post #625702 - Reply to (#625441) by godlover
user avatar
 Member

3:05 pm, Dec 23 2013
Posts: 445


Quote from godlover
I think it is wrong to read "hentai without borderline h" because it is porn.I consider porn and masturbation to be completely wrong.So,That's why I said "hentai without borderline h" is wrong.Now,are you clear? i e for me porn is morally wrong to read(according to me).

I'm itching to answer, oh my god i so want to answer for you, but i think, probably i would be banned from this forum so i keep silent.

user avatar


3:54 pm, Dec 23 2013
Posts: 10658


Basically same as http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=11629 but expanding genres to also tags (which didn't exist when that thread was started)

I guess while I'm at it, I'll changing the title of the other thread to "Genres/Tags you don't like"

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
You must be registered to post!