Main character chooses The Other Guy

12 years ago
Posts: 9
I hate love triangles. Really and truly, I do. There are some that pull it off nicely, some that wrench my heart, and some that are hardly noticeable. But most the time, they are annoying. ANNOYING.
So I'm looking for stories where the main character chooses that guy. Stories where they have a crush on their childhood friend, but then fall in love with someone else. Stories where they are in love with someone for what feels like forever, but they meet someone new and end up (consciously or subconsciously) falling for them instead. I'll even take stories where they are in a relationship with someone and fall for someone else during, though I don't prefer those.
No yaoi, preferably shoujo, but I'll take shounen, seinen, josei, webcomic, and manhwa with boy or girl main character. Romance doesn't have to be main focus, but obviously has to be present.
Examples include:
Celeste Blue
18 Diary
Blanc Marie
Candy Flower
D-Frag! Kind of. I'm a Kazama/Takao shipper, so that's what I mean 😛
Everybody Loves Somebody This one is pretty much the personified version of what I mean.
Katakoi Triangle
Lovey Dovey
Otokomae! Beads Club if you squint. Regardless, if you have manga like this one, recommend it 😀
Hidarite no Love Letter
Tokyo Kareshi
I really hate childhood friend stories, so I really want ones where they don't choose them.
Thank you so much! 🙂
"You may not remember me but I've seen you through the TV."
--Dale Gribble

12 years ago
Posts: 442
Cat Street, if I remember correctly. But it's got a lot of other drama 🙂
Go to work, send your kids to school;
Follow fashion, act normal;
Walk on the pavement, watch T.V.;
Save for retirement, obey the law.
Repeat after me: I am free.

12 years ago
Posts: 2964

12 years ago
Posts: 31
12 years ago
Posts: 428

12 years ago
Posts: 31

12 years ago
Posts: 981
Gokusen
Hot Gimmick
Hana yori Dango
Romance Papa - reading this now, and seems to be going that way
Otona Pink, and the guy she dumped didn't deserve it >:-(
Akuma na Eros
Benkyou no Jikan, story 3 "So, Stand By Me"
12 years ago
Posts: 251

12 years ago
Posts: 9
Thanks so much for all the suggestions, you guys 😀 😀
"You may not remember me but I've seen you through the TV."
--Dale Gribble

12 years ago
Posts: 94
Onani Master Kurosawa kind of fits. The person chosen at the end is a surprise.

12 years ago
Posts: 29
how about Moe Kare!!
I read it a long time ago but I remember I really ended up rooting for the other guy. 🙂
12 years ago
Posts: 20
Futari no Himitsu. by Moro Orie
I recommend this one, it's really good 😀

12 years ago
Posts: 400
Try... Molester Man
12 years ago
Posts: 41
This kind of thread pops up occasionally. I always recommend Peach Girl for this, though it spoils the ending for you.
Open Sesame fits
"I already decided I'll do it, so even if I die fighting for that cause, that's fine with me."
"Who the hell do you think I am?!"