Baka-Updates Manga - Viewing Topic - Naruto, Bleach, & One Piece

Forums

Main Index | New Posts ( all ) | Search Forums

Naruto, Bleach, & One Piece

Back to Shounen/Seinen

Poll

the three competing manga, vote to your reasonable judgements, time to see which is the most epic !!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Naruto < Bleach < One Piece

One Piece < Bleach < Naruto

Naruto < One Piece < Bleach

Bleach < Naruto < One Piece

One Piece < Naruto < Bleach

Bleach < One Piece < Naruto

You must login to vote.

Pages (10) [ 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Last ] Next

You must be registered to post!

From User

Message Body

Walrothetacoking

Post #228213 - Reply to (#228194) by loosecannon504

Demented Octopus
Member

12:18 am, Nov 15 2008
Posts: 737

Quote from loosecannon504

I chose "One Piece < Naruto < Bleach"

it should be noted those are less than and not greater than signs in there; the poll choices are all listed from least favorite to favorite for some reason. You and probably others voted for the exact wrong choice. As such, I really question the validity of this poll.

________________
Tree + Taco = Tree taco.

Monstar Maalik

Post #228227 - Reply to (#228194) by loosecannon504

uhh...
Member

2:37 am, Nov 15 2008
Posts: 1034

Quote from loosecannon504

I chose "One Piece < Naruto < Bleach"

With One Piece, I feel satisfied when every chapter. The writing's better, the action's better, and there's more dialogue and more action scenes in every chapter than Naruto and Bleach. With the other two, they'd need to release two chapters every time just to get on par with One Piece in my opinion.

Naruto's second because it does tend to get a little boring at times, and the whole "Ha, I killed him/her! No you didn't, that was my clone! Eat this and die! Oh no!" thing is being done in EVERY fight lately. But Kishimoto is trying to spice up that formula (Killerbee and Kakashi's trick clones were GENIUS), so I still look forward to read it every week.

Now Bleach...

can anyone SERIOUSLY rate Bleach above One Piece and Naruto as it is right now? It used to be so good, but right after the Zaraki/Nnoitra fight, it's like it started throwing up the most obvious cliches. The plot hasn't progressed for about 20 chapters, and then the character development became absolutely horrid (Soi Fon, A CAPTAIN, getting beat up by a FRACCION?). It made me so disappointed that I'm off of it until March (Hopefully, the plot would've progressed by then).

Quote from Monstar Maalik

i think i voted wrong but...

One Peice..........................< Naruto... < Bleach

I second this by infinity.

i agree with you 1000% but i think we did it wrong.....

i think it should be

One Piece................................> Naruto..... > Bleach

but yeah, One Piece deserves all its popularity, it has a very deep plot most the time, at least for the type of manga it is.....Naruto can be great somtimes, sometimes not so much...and Bleach has just been going downhill for a very long time now

________________
User Posted Image

Scyfon

Post #228235

Mome Basher
Member

3:33 am, Nov 15 2008
Posts: 3380

Recently, it's been like One Piece > Bleach > Naruto for me :\

________________
User Posted Image

Everyday I'm tumblin'

loosecannon504

Post #228294 - Reply to (#228213) by Walrothetacoking

The Gorilla Killa™
Member

10:59 am, Nov 15 2008
Posts: 3229

Quote from Walrothetacoking

Quote from loosecannon504

I chose "One Piece < Naruto < Bleach"

Quote from Monstar Maalik

Quote from loosecannon504

Quote from Monstar Maalik

i think i voted wrong but...

One Peice..........................< Naruto... < Bleach

I second this by infinity.

Everyone, start facepalming my vote for the good of teh internetz.

I'll start.
User Posted Image

Last edited by loosecannon504 at 11:27 am, Nov 15 2008

________________

Quote from Klapzi

The cool part is that I never get tired of being deceived

Quote from tactics

Just because someone's head was chopped off doesn't mean they're dead. That's just silly.

jpnraw

Post #228306

Member

11:34 am, Nov 15 2008
Posts: 185

I picked " Bleach < Naruto < One Piece"

=]

________________
User Posted Image

Iahel

Post #228577

off-hour sardaukar
Member

4:15 pm, Nov 16 2008
Posts: 60

strange Japanese-style poll roll eyes

as for me One Piece > Naruto > Bleach
One Piece earns plus not only for great plot and characters but also for really great environment development. Oda-san uses everything starting Venice and ending Indian culture melting it with his own fantasy. and every chapter is full of new information. every chapter is really important.
Naruto is always something special for me, 'cause it was a the first manga for me. cool

and Bleach become more and more predictable. all those inevitable fights and browned off sleights make manga so boring. everybody knows that no one will win without being beat at least once by it's competitor. dropped for a while after a flash-back ark.

________________
Paradise on my right, Hell on my left and the Angel of Death behind.
http://iahel.tumblr.com

BerserkFan

Post #228628

Member

9:40 pm, Nov 16 2008
Posts: 64

Naruto = One Piece, The best shounens EVER . eyes

Bleach...It started well but then became an average shounen.... none

bluegreenangel

Post #228754 - Reply to (#228628) by BerserkFan

Member

12:39 pm, Nov 17 2008
Posts: 370

Quote from BerserkFan

Naruto = One Piece, The best shounens EVER . eyes

Bleach...It started well but then became an average shounen.... none

bleach's anonymous success has been just a fluke... i mean think about it, soul society was a big success because of the fact that the character development effected the plot in a domino effect, the way they introduced all these captains and lietenants was pretty smart... i guess the author thought he would use the same idea twice, and didnt turn out well as luckily as the first one... i mean, whats the point of introducing characters thats ganna die just like that, i guess its also because there werent much deaths in characters, thats why the character could evolve more...

SoY

Post #235310

Lacuna
Member

7:47 am, Dec 7 2008
Posts: 42

one piece > naruto>bleach

One piece - the only manga that can make me laugh and cry (:sob smile

u know, in arabasta, when, the hawk carry the bom to the sky and explode..

Naruto - i still read it, bcause i want to know how it will end.

Bleach - i think it's okay, the fight and how every character have special skill.. i still read it if i have spare time cool

________________
yaha.....

angelwriter

Post #251159

Member

5:45 pm, Jan 22 2009
Posts: 24

ok...
naruto... unfortuneatly from my point of view is plain crap.
and that's me trying to be kind.
bleach is more... i dunno...
serious... so if ur up for some laughter, ditch it.
plus the story kinda... lags on for quite a bit... and after maybe 10 or so chapters does something actually happen.
but by then... you probs don't realise becus you're tired already.
as for one piece...
i was one of those ppl who cudnt be bothered with it cus it looked... well... yeh. like that.
but after i started reading it...
addictive.
very funny...
and its great hoe everything gets pulled back together to make all the sense in the world.
so tah
thats all.
ciao

________________
WONGI = a little bit of this and a little bit of that

tactics

Post #251400

Is a female

Member

8:20 am, Jan 23 2009
Posts: 3457

Fuck me I voted wrong.

God damn stupid "<" and ">" Argh!

I don't want to think maths when i'm on the computer. I have enough maths in my life thanks dead

Well, I have never read one piece. I'm too scared to get started on it because it's so LONG.

So for me, it'd go Naruto, Bleach, One Piece.

I think I accidently voted for the otherway around though. Silly me laugh

NightSwan

Post #251406

Mad With a Hat
Member

8:45 am, Jan 23 2009
Posts: 4764

Eh?... What is this doing in Manga General?
Moved.

Since I didn't like either naruto or bleach, I go with One Piece (watched some of the anime and it was nice).

________________
Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
User Posted Image

And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.

Click 'n Play!

If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.

kaeleer

Post #251417 - Reply to (#251400) by tactics

Member

9:00 am, Jan 23 2009
Posts: 103

I think I voted right. One Piece is better than Naruto, which is better than Bleach ....
Bleach < Naruto < One Piece

I've never really read Naruto before, but my friend adores it and I'll go with her opinion. I read Bleach, and it would have AWESOME if they ended it after the Soul Society arc. When they got back home and started dealing with the Espada, I just got so bored I kinda let it die off. It also made me happy that Kubo stopped Zombie Powder when he did, I can adore it and not feel the least bit annoyed!

That being said, One Piece remains my baby. biggrin

{I find it better though when I give it a long break and read the chapters back to back}

Quote from tactics

Well, I have never read one piece. I'm too scared to get started on it because it's so LONG.

Wikipedia is your friend here~! bigrazz

{Find the character who appeals to you the most and read their intro arc then jump around, or get right into the current arc. I did that with Ace and TA-DA! I was hooked}

Helaine

Post #251914

Member

5:31 am, Jan 25 2009
Posts: 20

argh I voted One Piece < Naruto < Bleach by accident!!!

I actually wanted to vote Bleach < Naruto < One Piece

________________
User Posted Image