banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Random Questions "Attempt II"

Pages (198) [ First ... 144 145 146 Last ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #475468
user avatar
Site Admin

2:19 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 2275


They are not really tiny Hanae. Well, comparing them to other stellar bodies, they are... but in the scheme of the universe, everything else is small.

Now, the reason we can't measure black holes directly is do to all information being sucked into it, not the size of the object. The red line in the black hole representation indicates where all information gathering stops (not drawn to scale, yeah).

And we don't know that black holes exist by the absence of information... black holes were a mathematical prediction. When matter/light does not cross the event horizon (invisible line of no return), there is still a pull on everything around it, which distorts the matter/light. So, we can only "see" black holes from the interactions of everything around it: such as, the massive stars at the center of our galaxy, which loops around an invisible object.

User Posted Image

________________
"Officially, this machine doesn't exist, you didn't get it from me,
and I don't know you. Make sure it doesn't leave the building."
Post #475471 - Reply to (#475303) by WandereroftheDeep
user avatar
Member

2:40 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 161


Quote from WandereroftheDeep
Quote from Pocono
exactly, rest energy wink .. but usally light doesnt rest..thats what i meant when i said too difficult to explain.
and the whole concept of light interacting with gravity is a very fundamental statement of the general theory of relativity
also im actually an idiot XD ...cause what i described about the light going in a circle around the earth is practically a black hole so yes, you can calculate that if the earth had the same mass it has right now, and a radius of 9 mm !! it would go in a circle around the earth. as a comparison, right now the radius is about 6300 km which is 6 300 000 000 mm .... so the line is pretty straight wink


Black holes are said to have infinite density; so, is it really possible to determine that if the earth became a black hole, which is probably impossible, would have a radius of 9mm?
And then there's the matter of "dark matter" they still haven't got figured out yet bigrazz

The size of a black hole is dependent solely on its mass. You can calculate the radius of its event horizon from its mass, which can be found by measuring the way in which light and other bodies curve around it.

Post #475496 - Reply to (#475303) by WandereroftheDeep
user avatar
Member

7:20 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 176


Quote from Binturong
im still not convinced.

maybe because you,re an idiot...and i mean that as nice as possible...


Quote from WandereroftheDeep
Quote from Pocono
exactly, rest energy wink .. but usally light doesnt rest..thats what i meant when i said too difficult to explain.
and the whole concept of light interacting with gravity is a very fundamental statement of the general theory of relativity
also im actually an idiot XD ...cause what i described about the light going in a circle around the earth is practically a black hole so yes, you can calculate that if the earth had the same mass it has right now, and a radius of 9 mm !! it would go in a circle around the earth. as a comparison, right now the radius is about 6300 km which is 6 300 000 000 mm .... so the line is pretty straight wink


Black holes are said to have infinite density; so, is it really possible to determine that if the earth became a black hole, which is probably impossible, would have a radius of 9mm?
And then there's the matter of "dark matter" they still haven't got figured out yet bigrazz

no thats where you are wrong, using infinite is kinda tricky here, thats the problem when you talk about physics without using math.
what a black hole is, is an object in space time that is "cut off" from the environment. that means no light (and hence everything else, like information) can escape it. the density doesnt have to be infinite. if the earh had a radius of 9mm the denisity would be so high that not even light could escape its gravitational field..that makes it a black hole.

Post #475498 - Reply to (#475496) by Pocono
user avatar
Member

7:56 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 761


Quote from Pocono
no thats where you are wrong, using infinite is kinda tricky here, thats the problem when you talk about physics without using math.
what a black hole is, is an object in space time that is "cut off" from the environment. that means no light (and hence everything else, like information) can escape it. the density doesnt have to be infinite. if the earh had a radius of 9mm the denisity would be so high that not even light could escape its gravitational field..that makes it a black hole.


Um, I think that it only means thatif we, um... squeezed the Earth so that it has a radius of 9 mm, it would be so thick that it would become a black hole. But it doesn't mean that the black hole which would appear would have a 9 mm radius... I can't find a source to prove it and it's just what I think... but I think that the actual size of a black hole can't be measured and their "size" is just how strongly they suck in matter

Post #475505 - Reply to (#475498) by Hanae
user avatar
Member

9:33 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 176


Quote from Hanae
Um, I think that it only means thatif we, um... squeezed the Earth so that it has a radius of 9 mm, it would be so thick that it would become a black hole. But it doesn't mean that the black hole which would appear would have a 9 mm radius... I can't find a source to prove it and it's just what I think... but I think that the actual size of a black hole can't be measured and their "size" is just how strongly they suck in matter

yes yes : ) .. i never wanted to make any statement about the "size" of a bh....its a kinda tricky thing, as the pic above shows, theoretically it all comes together in a sigle point called the singularity.
my point is only in refrence to the question at the beginning...if we make the earth,s radius a tiny bit bigger than 9mm then we,d have light circling around it..which is kinda cool o.o
actually now that makes me wonder what our perception of the world would be like if the light would be influenced like that...heh

user avatar
Member

11:22 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 707


Does studying black holes actually help anyone??

Post #475521 - Reply to (#475515) by Binturong
user avatar
Mmm...Tasty
Member

11:47 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 497


Quote from Binturong
Does studying black holes actually help anyone??


laugh
It does; it can save certain people from boredom bigrazz

________________
User Posted Image
Post #475523 - Reply to (#475450) by Casey D. Geek
user avatar
Member

11:55 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 510


Quote from Casey D. Geek
Which version of The Elements of Style, authored by William Strunk Jr. and a varying - and confusing - list authors would you recommend, and why?

Whichever one you want, though the usual/classic one is Strunk and White, and I'd go for any of those 'cause EB White is an awesome author, knows what he's talking about, and it's the one I have 'cause used editions can be found for dirt cheap. But, for a current and utterly useful style book, I'm a huge fan of Ann Stillman's Grammatically Correct.

Quote from Binturong
what makes physics interesting??

The labs are totally awesome.

Post #475524
user avatar
Member

11:57 am, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 176


thats a very close minded question. science exists for itself, it doesnt need a justification.

but if you really want one, there are many. studying unknow objects such as a bh might give you insights into new laws of physics, and even tho you might not see the purpose of those laws right away, pretty much everything becomes "usefull" (whatever you mean by that) sooner or later.
e.g. since we,re talking about general relativity, only becauase of that theory we do know how an information signal behaves when it travels brom the earth to a satelite. without the general theory of relativity GPS would not work, because the "classical" laws would calculate you a wrong position.

if it wasnt for ppl studying stuff that has no evident application, we,d still be living in caves...more or less.

user avatar
Certified addict
 Member

8:46 pm, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 301


Does trolling actually help anyone??

________________
User Posted Image
Post #475603 - Reply to (#475600) by Turbophoenix
user avatar
Member

9:13 pm, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 1027


Quote from Turbophoenix
Does trolling actually help anyone??


It helps the troll population.

________________
If the sea were made of Whiskey and I was a duck
I'd swim to the bottom and never come up
Post #475604 - Reply to (#475603) by bedob
user avatar
Member

9:18 pm, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 636


Quote from bedob
Quote from Turbophoenix
Does trolling actually help anyone??


It helps the troll population.


That rarely needs any help

________________
"It is those who know little, and not those who know much, who so positively assert that this or that problem will never be solved by science."
Post #475618 - Reply to (#475523) by story645
user avatar
Meh...
Member

10:54 pm, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 937


Quote from story645
Quote from Casey D. Geek
Which version of The Elements of Style, authored by William Strunk Jr. and a varying - and confusing - list authors would you recommend, and why?

Whichever one you want, though the usual/classic one is Strunk and White, and I'd go for any of those 'cause EB White is an awesome author, knows what he's talking about, and it's the one I have 'cause used editions can be found for dirt cheap. But, for a current and utterly useful style book, I'm a huge fan of Ann Stillman's Grammatically Correct.


Thanks smile
Quote
Quote from Binturong
what makes physics interesting??

The labs are totally awesome.

Again, wish I was that lucky bigrazz


________________
There are times when you will miss what you never had. I wonder how you will find what you so desperately need.
Post #475619 - Reply to (#475603) by bedob
user avatar
Member

11:09 pm, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 3120


Quote from bedob
Quote from Turbophoenix
Does trolling actually help anyone??

It helps the troll population.

It cures syphilis, supposedly.

Post #475624 - Reply to (#475619) by Sagaris
user avatar
Mome Basher
Member

11:18 pm, Jun 10 2011
Posts: 3380


Quote from Sagaris
Quote from bedob
Quote from Turbophoenix
Does trolling actually help anyone??

It helps the troll population.

It cures syphilis, supposedly.

and Aids. Don't forget Aids.


...but it also gives you cancer D:

________________
User Posted Image
Everyday I'm tumblin'
Pages (198) [ First ... 144 145 146 Last ] Next
You must be registered to post!