I made something pointless. I gathered 20 people i know and put their manga scores in a list. i also put MAL score to see the difference. Among the ones i counted so far, only one manga was underrated.

Top 40 Manga with at least 7 votes


Most overrated manga


Of course this list is 100 % not accurate. It is just a representation of some group`s taste.

I didn`t put many manga, just the ones in top of my head. I didnt have many people get votes for other manga.

If you wish to see the full sheet, be my guest: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wXRQKtjYkA7oiD5R 6jBAl1UNW18BdZshV7eCq6GSx6M/edit?usp=sharing