Well... I probably stick longer with manga that has a good plot, but sometimes I don't mind a weak plot if the art is amazing, like in Alichino.
________________
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Art vs. Plot
From User
Message Body
Post #275657
Member
12:52 pm, Apr 13 2009
Posts: 522
12:52 pm, Apr 13 2009
Posts: 522
The art is very important for me. If the art fails...I won't consider reading the manga even if the plot is interesting. I read manga for their beautiful art. If it's just for the plot, I can stick to some novels.
Member
1:02 pm, Apr 13 2009
Posts: 60
1:02 pm, Apr 13 2009
Posts: 60
I used to decide which mangas i read based on the art
after coming across so many mangas with nice art and no substance (in the plot), i've come to change my mind
i pick plot. if the art's pretty with no plot line, there's really no point in reading the manga.
after coming across so many mangas with nice art and no substance (in the plot), i've come to change my mind
i pick plot. if the art's pretty with no plot line, there's really no point in reading the manga.
Bazooka .
Member
1:38 pm, Apr 13 2009
Posts: 603
If the art isn't good ,I won't even bother reading it.The plot may be good and all,but I just can't read something when I hate the art!
If the art is really good , but the plot sucks, I may consider reading it anyways.
________________
*click*I THINK EDWARD CULLEN IS UGLY.*click*
If the art is really good , but the plot sucks, I may consider reading it anyways.
________________
*click*I THINK EDWARD CULLEN IS UGLY.*click*
Post #276158
BiG MonKeY
Member
5:09 am, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 94
i prefer pretty arts but for me it's not the most important element of a manga
i'll read a manga as long as it has a good plot
________________
Tom4toes!!!!
Chick3n!!!!
Fo0d!!!!
i'll read a manga as long as it has a good plot
________________
Tom4toes!!!!
Chick3n!!!!
Fo0d!!!!
Member
5:13 am, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 1
5:13 am, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 1
I perfer a good plot to good art, so if the art is good, but the plot sucks i won't read it.
omega blue
Member
10:29 am, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 46
I prefer a nice art. I like to draw manga myself.. so its pretty important. But of course if the story sucks there is no meaning in reading it.
For example Vampire Knight.. the art is superb but the story just got to obscure.
For example Vampire Knight.. the art is superb but the story just got to obscure.
Member
10:43 am, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 1762
10:43 am, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 1762
I think plot is slightly more important than art. If the story's not interesting, it doesn't matter how great the drawings are. Even if the art is not done well, I will still finish it.
Member
9:09 pm, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 16
9:09 pm, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 16
I've noticed that when the art is better, I tend to invest myself more emotionally and I really get into the story. Examples would be Mekakushi no Kuni, works by Sahara Mizu, Mars, etc etc.
Wonky proportions tend to bother me, so even while I do read a lot of manga with not-so-great art, I enjoy the ones with better art more.
~Polecat
________________
For alacrity and effulgence in all things manga: http://mangameditation.blogspot.com
Wonky proportions tend to bother me, so even while I do read a lot of manga with not-so-great art, I enjoy the ones with better art more.
~Polecat
________________
For alacrity and effulgence in all things manga: http://mangameditation.blogspot.com
Post #276436
Member
9:18 pm, Apr 15 2009
Posts: 92
Art vs. Plot
two words:
Angel Densetsu
________________
If you're old enough....
Support single moms
two words:
Angel Densetsu
________________
If you're old enough....
Support single moms
I like a little bit of both.I mean,seriously, if you wanna read a story,might as well have everything you want in it,right? So the art should be pretty decent.I like plots thats light-hearted,but somewhat teaches a lesson or makes you realize something.When i'm feeling down i read stories that makes you treasure life.But yeah, the answer is pretty clear:i need both.
Post #296480
Member
9:47 pm, Jun 8 2009
Posts: 49
Art helps. I think a manga needs good art no matter what. I don't want to look at stick figures while I read the plot. but, if the story sucks, I will stop reading it too.
Post #296717
Member
5:34 pm, Jun 9 2009
Posts: 17
The most important thing is plot, it has to be interesting and not lose my attention. But if the art is absolutely horrible I wont consider it either . Plot is more important than the art, but art is still important.
________________
________________
vymletoza
Member
5:45 pm, Jun 9 2009
Posts: 180
Member
5:45 pm, Jun 9 2009
Posts: 180
Plot is the most important thing. I was disapponted several times by great art with stupid plot. Of course, I give some points to art too. Especially bodies. I can´t read something with bad drawn bodies. Like Tokyo crazy paradise and Kodomo no omocha. But I rate most by plots, not art.
________________
I´m NOT an alien!
________________
I´m NOT an alien!
Member
6:07 am, Jun 17 2009
Posts: 27
6:07 am, Jun 17 2009
Posts: 27
In deciding to try a new manga, I consider the art first. I'm very picky when it comes to art, which I prefer to be at least proportional and consistent, because it makes the manga more appealing. Still, the plot is the most important factor because a well developing plot will keep me in reading it. I don't want to waste time on wonderfully drawn manga while the story goes no where. But even with a good story, I will not enjoy it fully if the art is so bad.
Search
- MANGA Fu
- News
- What's New!
- Series Stats
- Forums
- Releases
- Scanlators
- Series Info
- Mangaka
- Publishers
- Reviews
- Genres
- Categories
- FAQ
- Members
- API
- MEMBERS
- Sign Up
- TEAM-BU
- Admin CP
- About Us