This story is terribly sentimental, yet irresistibly sexy and very well-drawn! It drives you nuts at times with its unexpected twists and the characters' promiscuity, and yet you are unable to break away and hunger for what happens next. Unlike the highschool-ish chick-flick kind of love story like Boku wa Imōto ni Koi o Suru, Tsumi ni Nureta Futari's love story is deeper, more mature, more sweetly agonizing...

I wouldn't put it as one of my favorite reads but hell, I'm addicted to it!!

I really don't know what to say about this manga.

I am NOT against incest, since i believe love comes in many form and should not be labeled.

Pro: Mature art style. Deep love. Drama. Slice of life. Good plotline.

Con: Too soap opera. Killed me so many times withe the drama. Not yet complete scanlate. 80% this manga will never make it to the licensed world since many are against incest (Through many accepts yaoi and hentai since whatever-reason). For angst lovers more than shoujo/happy-ending lovers (Me).

Extra Note: Waiting to see all 18 volumes scanlated.

Rate: I'm a picky person (especially when it comes to manga), so a 6/10 for me. 6/10 may not seem much but coming from me really means it's a worth reading!! (Death Note being 7/10, PoT 7/10, Love Monster 7.5/10, Vampire Knight 8/10, One Piece 9/10, Hikaru no go 10/10).

i love this manga, it makes you hope for the best for them.

One of my favorites series, a little to filled with drama at times tho.

THE BEST MANGA EVER. the story is great, the drawings too, and the story is made the way that you understand their relationship.
My favorite

This is overdue but for the fans of Tsumi Ni Nureta Futari, we made a thank you portrait ss celebration for our achievement of finishing the chapters (and it’s 20th anniversary), we made a portrait of me, avalanche (anonymous), the author Miyuki Kitagawa, and the cast of characters for our one wild ride! We can not be any prouder! Thank you.

https://midnightdreamscans.wordpress.com/2019/02/25/tsumi-ni-nureta-futari-sp ecial-thanks-portrait/?fbclid=IwAR1znzFLxSulXY_qORyxiUDBoiFU9wFY8ske8iue3Pft_ PplwEKmofZElOY

This is a very good story and honestly most of the characters aren't that bad, however it suffers greatly because of the moronic main protagonist. I liked her at first but it didn't take long for her to reveal that she loves nothing more than being the cause of all the trouble around her. A lot of problems would have been solved if she'd just been honest with her feelings, but nope, gotta sleep with her friend for absolutely no reason. I still love this, but I feel so bad for her brother who was actually the only decent person around. The male lead is really the main reason to read this, everything else is meh

... Last updated on August 7th, 2016, 11:09pm

I suddenly remembered it, though I've finished reading it long ago. what wasn't scanlated can be found in raw... unfortunately my Japanese is... nonexistent, so me and google translate became BFFs, but it is totally recommended for reading. True, it has lots of smut in it. Way too much in my opinion (hey, I love smut!) but the main male character was so worth it. The woman - meh.

Like I said in my subject box...one big soap opera. In the beginning it's really good, still good in the middle end but then I realized for me the middle end was volume 7 or so. That's when I came to note that this serious has 18 volumes! They have so much drama already in 7 volumes, how can they do more in 18? After a while I skipped around and then just straight to the end. Pretty draggy story on and on I gotta say. I mean it's good, and I don't care about the incest part. It makes the story better, without it...it would be nothing of course. The one thing that bugged me though was that the girl kept on going back to him and then would say no I should then go back to him again, then repeat repeat. Seriously c'mon! Make up your mind. Also the ex's boyfriend/girlfriend for the siblings were partially annoying as well. But once again, without them the story would be kapeeeesh. The art is rather very good for something made in 1999 (you don't see that often.) You should give it a shot! I like it overall though. I'd give it an 8. Also the ending is a total twist, it got me crying at first. I'm a sucker for endings I guess.

... Last updated on October 6th, 2008, 2:43am

though i did somewhat like this manga, the main character Kasumi is always freaking crying which annoys the heck out of me... its a never ending soap. The artwork is okay, its nothing really special at all. If you just want to pass time because you have nothing else better to do then read this