I want to strongly recommend this manga unlike any other shoujo romance manga where there is a love triangle this one is pretty much the main girl only love the main guy and the main guy only loves the main girl and no one can tear them apart. There is no sex involve or even hinting of sex. Just plain traditional love which i like.

I didn't expect much from this series when I first started reading it, but I found myself hooked in no time... somehow reading this manga made me feel really, really good and happy (although, yes, there were some sad elements that made me tear up as well).

Overall, I found it to be a very heartwarming and enjoyable read, with none of the annoying characters that typically abound in shoujo series. And I agree with Odette, Arou is one of the kindest male protagonists I've seen in a shoujo manga. Heh, and he's definitely my favorite character: kind, sweet, loyal, and a little emotionally-fragile; never a mean word out of his mouth toward Kanade (except maybe a few teasing words at the very beginning). Gaahh, if only this guy were real (lol). READ THIS SERIES!

... Last updated on April 29th, 2009, 1:56am

It's one of the stories that make you feel good after you've read them. Maybe not particularly deep(well, in fact it's pretty shallow) but heartwarming, cute, and funny. There is a wee bit of drama, but not as much as I expected considering the setup.
It clearly shows that mangaka loves his characters, as in the end pretty much everybody turns out to actually be a good person.
And, the following conversation was awesome:
Arou: "I would like to have another present... that is... I want you!"
Kanade: "All right!" with a broad smile on her face... Simply amazing.
All in all, maybe it wasn't a masterpiece, but it was certainly an enjoyable read. If you don't require your manga to be filled with angst and suffering, be sure to check it out.

their love for each other is sooo cute!!!!!!!!
i did wished that the draws could be more serious at times, but i still loved it every much

The whole story was amazingly and beautifully told..! The artwork was so great and really helped to play out the image of the storyline! Even if this book was a novel without pictures...it would still be a sight to behold and I would continuously read it over and over...!

Though I must admit that I almost didn't read it because of the genre it was in...but I'm glad I did because it turned out to be one of my all time favorite manga EVER!!!!

Highly recommended to all manga audience!!!

i really liked it so hands down for the mangaka.i really like her work (i also read pinguin revolution , which was made by her and it was great) .the story is heart warming and i realy really liked it

... Last updated on December 22nd, 2009, 6:27pm

A good story that tends to wander in different directions. The characters' complex pasts seem like they should angst more - I almost feel as if the story wasn't dramatic enough. Still, I enjoyed the read.

cool manga..the romance of d main character with some trust..plus with the supernatural things..what can i say~hope d story never end..

very touching story! love the guys ;)

Hmmm, I really don't have anything bad to say about this, I reeeallly didn't want to read this manga and have been putting it off for about a year, but after struggling for 2months as to whether I should read this, I gave in.This mangas good buut...I'm just not in the mood for this atm...its tooo slow and I just want something interesting and fastly paced...so imma read this later ....I think :L