banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Star Trek VS. Star Wars

Poll
Which is better?
Star Trek
Star Wars
Can't stand either.
Like both equally!
You must login to vote.

Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Member

3:50 pm, Aug 7 2009
Posts: 227


I prefer Star Wars. I think it's got more of an ability to appeal to a wider audience, plus I grew up loving it. biggrin

Post #311852
user avatar
Member

4:22 pm, Aug 7 2009
Posts: 838


I go with Star trek because its older and more likely to happend in a future. And i have lots of fond memories with it.

user avatar


7:40 pm, Aug 7 2009
Posts: 10661


Both rock for me. Although I can't wait for The Old Republic to come out...

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
Post #311975
user avatar
Member

12:10 am, Aug 8 2009
Posts: 1354


Lol, Star Wars is winning! *keeps eye on poll* I'll return for a longer discussion after more votes are in. biggrin

Post #311977
user avatar
Resident Odd
Member

12:38 am, Aug 8 2009
Posts: 665


Ooh, I love both series!

Star Wars feels more like Fantasy rather than Sci-Fi, while Star Trek is more Sci-Fi-ish.

I've been a fan of both for decades, though I admittedly haven't seen much of the original Star Trek series. I've watched most of Next Generation, Voyager, and Deep Space Nine, however.

Of Star Wars, I prefer the original trilogy. It was just awesome back in the day. I've read a bit of the Extended Universe novels, but I grew distant from them when:

Spoiler (highlight to view)
Anakin Solo and Chewbacca died. ARGH!





________________
http://eofusion.googlepages.com
http://360.yahoo.com/axisofoddity
http://axisofoddity.googlepages.com/
Post #311981
user avatar
The Kekkaishi
Member

12:48 am, Aug 8 2009
Posts: 250


Okay so i used to love star wars more than manga about 2 years ago (omg i know!) even though i dont like it as much anymore i think i prefer it to star trek. Not saying i dislike star trek, i love voyager and enterprise series and some of next generation!

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

5:20 am, Aug 8 2009
Posts: 211


I've never watched star trek, but i love star wars!

user avatar
So Innocent
Member

8:57 am, Aug 8 2009
Posts: 288


I'm sorry Star Trek and Star Wars fans because I hate them both.

P.s. I feel riot about to happen and I about to be banned from the forums laugh

________________
Would I lie to you?
Post #312036
user avatar
Member

9:34 am, Aug 8 2009
Posts: 2342


Well maybe people would understand if you gave reasons?

user avatar
African Albino Cat
Member

10:13 am, Aug 8 2009
Posts: 677


For me;

Star Trek: I only like the the even number episodes.

Star Wars: I only like episode 1, 4, 5, and 6.

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Madman
 Moderator

4:05 pm, Aug 9 2009
Posts: 3342


Star wars

Why? because I like the storyline better.

________________
"“That's the difference between me and the rest of the world!
Happiness isn't good enough for me! I demand euphoria!” "
Post #312373 - Reply to (#311809) by The Guy
user avatar
Couch-Fu Master
 Member

9:55 pm, Aug 9 2009
Posts: 160


Quote from The Guy
Quote from Ghaz
To put it bluntly star wars is on the level with movies like Yojimbo, Seven samurai, A Fistfull of Dollars. While Star Trek is more along the lines of Beverly Hills 90210, or Degrassi High.


May I ask how you put the connection between a high standard, engaging, expansive and rather creative sci-fi series, and some third rate soap operas aimed at people with an IQ below 80?


Easily, and don't be offended I like Star Trek as a series. While the writing and plotlines of Star Trek are far more creative and thought out then the pointless dribble of a regular drama, it is still the same basic priniciple of those shows.

Star Trek had no planned ending, the show was based only around the weekly episode and had very little carry over, so that each episode had some inherit moral to the viewer, like all dramas.

Now when a television show focuses on plot driven action, which is based on the moral of the episode, there is very little actual charecter development (other then the basic story deveolpment of the charecter, ex-past, not mental, emotional, and very rarely ever physical devolpment, which adds depth) Where Star Wars has a planned begininng, middle, and end. Meaning there is only one moral inside the story, allowing for a story driven by actual charecter development, instead of shallow television topics that have been used in every show since I love lucy.

But that's a challenge all television shows have, how do you create a fresh topic weekly and still have actual depth to the cast, when everything has already been said before and you have tighter budgets to work with. To basically sum it up, Star Trek has more substance and value then Star Wars, but Star Wars is better storytelling due to the medium that it is (movie vs. T.V., big differences).

________________
Insert Catchy Signature Here.
Post #312375
user avatar
Yaaawn
Member

10:00 pm, Aug 9 2009
Posts: 746


Star Wars: I was a kid when some of the early Star Wars movies came out. I was captivated by them and can even remember some scenes now. I saw Star Trek too, but Star Wars was always more fascinating to a child.

________________
User Posted Image
user avatar
Member

10:14 pm, Aug 9 2009
Posts: 30


Star Trek is the best sci-fi series to ever exist. Star Wars is nothing more than a typical action movie set in space, whereas Star Trek is a more probable portrayal of the future and did more to shed light on actual social issues in our world. Was there even really any moral storyline to Star Wars besides the typical good vs. evil?

Also, nothing in Star Wars really seemed new and intriguing to me. Star Trek was groundbreaking. It was the first time that a sci-fi futuristic space was shown as a functioning society and not just battles with aliens. It was also groundbreaking in terms of the racial diversity of its characters. While Star Wars might have been fun, Star Trek is absolute genius.

________________
Click here to learn the secrets of the universe!
Post #312384 - Reply to (#312378) by Kitsunebaby
user avatar
Member

10:36 pm, Aug 9 2009
Posts: 190


Quote from Kitsunebaby
Star Trek is the best sci-fi series to ever exist. Star Wars is nothing more than a typical action movie set in space, whereas Star Trek is a more probable portrayal of the future and did more to shed light on actual social issues in our world. Was there even really any moral storyline to Star Wars besides the typical good vs. evil?

Also, nothing in Star Wars really seemed new and intriguing to me. Star Trek was groundbreaking. It was the first time that a sci-fi futuristic space was shown as a functioning society and not just battles with aliens. It was also groundbreaking in terms of the racial diversity of its characters. While Star Wars might have been fun, Star Trek is absolute genius.


I agree with everything you just said. I don't have to write anything more than the fact I enjoy the original series quite alot.

I can't wait for the new BluRay for the JJ Abrams one.

________________
User Posted Image
Pages (3) [ 1 2 3 ] Next
You must be registered to post!