manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
Try out our new iPhone application!
Manga Poll
Your favorite series was dropped by the only group scanlating it, so you...
Find the raws and look at them without understanding the words
Ask other groups to pick it up
Bug the old group to pick it up again
Try to start your own scanlation group
Learn the language so that you can read it yourself
Look for summaries or synopsis to spoil yourself and feed the urge
Do nothing and wait patiently (sadly)
I already read the original language, so no worries
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates

RSS Feed
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

New Poll - Manga Quality Comparison

Back to News  See threaded view

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Post #539903
user avatar
Archon Solon

11:37 am, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 8367

This week's poll is from our member Lorska. What's your opinion of the current quality of manga (so stuff that's currently being released in Japan right now) compared to the quality of manga from previous years?

If you wanna discuss this, you can do so on our forums here:

You can submit poll ideas here (and try to keep them manga/anime-related):

Previous Poll Results:
Question: I prefer series with main characters that are
Younger than I am - votes: 814 (4.9%)
Approximately the same age as me - votes: 4512 (27%)
Older than me - votes: 1495 (8.9%)
No preference - votes: 7439 (44.4%)
I don't even notice their ages... - votes: 2482 (14.8%)
There were 16742 total votes.
The poll ended: March 10th 2012

Same age... Getting older every second. (Sorry, I'm currently pulling an all-nighter, and I can't think of anything better to say)

A just ruler amongst tyrants

MangaUpdates admin

Join the MangaUpdates Folding@Home team! (and help humanity)
Click here for info. Easy signup
Post #539904

1:13 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 16

The raws these days are pretty good, so I thing that more proofreaders are needed for good quality text.

Unless you're referring to the manga plot quality, then I thing that they're getting better. There's been an increase in better series in the recent years. The ones which are worse usually get flushed out anyway.

Post #539905
user avatar
Black Witch

1:14 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 381

Dont you mean "think" instead of "thing"
-Do you thing the quality of ...

If you want to succeed
Then you don't need Good Luck
You need the ability to overcome Bad Luck

Happines and Light needs a source to exist
Hatred fuels itself and Darkness exist where there is no Light

User Posted Image
Post #539906 - Reply to (#539904) by BedrosBoost

1:16 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 16

For those who say that manga in the past is better, that's mainly because the bad ones are never well known and the groups in the past would only scanlate the good ones. Take a look at all the groups these days, they're scanning everything, so now we get a pretty good picture of all the mangas getting released.

Post #539907 - Reply to (#539904) by BedrosBoost

3:37 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 61

Problem is that while the "worse ones" leave.........more (sometimes even larger numbers) come in to fill their spot.

ink junkie
Post #539908 - Reply to (#539907) by RiK.dfs

3:58 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 27

There's only more low-quality manga now because there's more manga in general. At the very least, the increasing number of people in the community increases our exposure to manga. Believe me, there's always been lots of crap.

Post #539909 - Reply to (#539906) by BedrosBoost
user avatar
animexis scans

5:13 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 13

"they are scanning everything?" man, you have no idea. I'm buying 6 manga magazines (Young Ace, Good Afternoon, Comic Valkyrie, Shonen Ace, LeParadise, 4Koma Nano Ace), that's around 80 different series and believe me, not even 30% of that gets scanlated. And some of those missing are really good series.

Post #539910 - Reply to (#539909) by Animexis

5:48 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 16

Yeah, you're right. They aren't scanning all of them but at least they're scanning a good number compared to the past. It just made me sad when you said that we're missing good series. sad

Post #539911 - Reply to (#539909) by Animexis

6:29 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 158

But if 70% doesn't get scanlated, doesn't that mean that (most of) the cream of the crop is ultimately being scanlated? If 30% of the stuff is (most of) the best, what does that say about the 70%?

Post #539912
user avatar

7:22 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 6

All in all the situation is not as bad as in the anime sector but I agree there are some bad manga that made me derping like hell.

Post #539913 - Reply to (#539905) by Lightmare
user avatar
✯ Sarcastic

8:02 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 597

I noticed, too, but he did say he was pulling an all-nighter. bigrazz

User Posted Image
Post #539914 - Reply to (#539908) by ink junkie

10:55 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 61

I meant larger number percentage wise. What's really needed though is people with good judgement willing to work on series that are actually good.

Unfortunately most people just take what they're given instead of building what they want.

The current trends in manga releases don't help much either (trends aren't very lasting).

Post #539915
An innocent

11:32 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 238

- quality of plot
- quality production (proper cover, good paper, proper setting of pages.... )
- quality story difference ( the originality of stories in general)
- quality of....

Might it be possible to make the question less vague, I understood the question as production quality, rather than plot quality first.

When their is hope, their is live.
Post #539916 - Reply to (#539915) by deadphoenix

11:56 pm, Mar 10 2012
Posts: 61

I think it means overall quality of the series (don't focus too much on the production part though since that isn't really always tied to the series but more to the publisher).

Post #539917 - Reply to (#539909) by Animexis
user avatar
still lurqing

4:44 am, Mar 11 2012
Posts: 333

highly agreeable. but by this time we should already know that even scanlators pick manga that can really bring readers in, no matter how uninteresting it might be compared to our hand-picked ones. still, i'm grateful some of those really good ones are getting scanlated. cheers for that biggrin

grammar mistake is intentional, grammar nazis need their entertainment.
Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to News  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
Manga Search