Spoiler (mouse over to view)
They have sex!
That's basically an automatic classification as Yuri. Seriously. Seeing as how Yuri is defined on this website, I think it would be obvious that that would be the case.
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Forums
It's definitely Yuri.
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member
1:32 pm, Sep 25 2012
Posts: 11
I mean
Mad With a Hat
Member
2:07 pm, Sep 25 2012
Posts: 4764
Your point?
Just add it to the genre list.
________________
Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
Click 'n Play!
If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.
Just add it to the genre list.
________________
Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
Click 'n Play!
If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.
Mythical Creature
Member
2:14 pm, Sep 25 2012
Posts: 285
It doesn't show them having sex though, so I wouldn't really count it
Member
2:42 pm, Sep 25 2012
Posts: 298
Actually, I don't quite see the point of two separate "lesbian" genres at all.
Shoujo-ai is supposedly the base genre for lesbian romance, subtext, and annoyingly often even just for side characters with (minor) lesbian tendencies.
Yuri is shoujo-ai topped with the occasional nudity and sex scenes.
Smut is the middelground between conservative/pure romance and full blown hentai.
Hentai is pure sex (18+ manga)
Ecchi for fanservice
... Why not simply combine smut and shoujo-ai instead of using yuri... Or simply get rid of shoujo-ai and replace it with Yuri altogether... Now MU kind of insinuates that Yuri means lesbian sex (which it does not).
And we now have to contend with 4 separate genres to indicate homosexual manga... Where 2 would suffice (and be better in my opinion), when having already indicated a manga deals with lesbian pairings, isn't a simple tag called "smut" enough?. I most certainly won't be confused by it... If you'd like to indicated a manga contains lesbian+gay pairing and gay sex only, that would be something for the "tags" (or categories), NOT genres.
So to respond at the topic title. YES, it's definitely Yuri. All manga containing Lesbian (romance) are.
Shoujo-ai is often the incorrect term, since it insinuates that it's love between (young) girls... Which kind of makes it also lolicon?
Anyway, /rant
________________
Who they, what are, and why?
- Manga Cover Database -
Shoujo-ai is supposedly the base genre for lesbian romance, subtext, and annoyingly often even just for side characters with (minor) lesbian tendencies.
Yuri is shoujo-ai topped with the occasional nudity and sex scenes.
Smut is the middelground between conservative/pure romance and full blown hentai.
Hentai is pure sex (18+ manga)
Ecchi for fanservice
... Why not simply combine smut and shoujo-ai instead of using yuri... Or simply get rid of shoujo-ai and replace it with Yuri altogether... Now MU kind of insinuates that Yuri means lesbian sex (which it does not).
And we now have to contend with 4 separate genres to indicate homosexual manga... Where 2 would suffice (and be better in my opinion), when having already indicated a manga deals with lesbian pairings, isn't a simple tag called "smut" enough?. I most certainly won't be confused by it... If you'd like to indicated a manga contains lesbian+gay pairing and gay sex only, that would be something for the "tags" (or categories), NOT genres.
So to respond at the topic title. YES, it's definitely Yuri. All manga containing Lesbian (romance) are.
Shoujo-ai is often the incorrect term, since it insinuates that it's love between (young) girls... Which kind of makes it also lolicon?
Anyway, /rant
________________
Who they, what are, and why?
- Manga Cover Database -
Mythical Creature
Member
2:48 pm, Sep 25 2012
Posts: 285
Lets just call it all manga.
Lone Wanderer
Member
11:51 pm, Oct 1 2012
Posts: 2127
Quote from Cthylla
It doesn't show them having sex though, so I wouldn't really count it
I agree with this. The way MU defines it, I'd say 'yuri' is when there's actual graphic sex depicted in the story, not when they mention it in passing/discuss it or cut-to-black and/or fadeout the 'scenes'. The one would-be-explicit shot in Candy was faded out, so it's not yuri.
As far as I'm aware, the way the English-speaking manga fandom categorizes BL and GL is different from how it's done in Japan. Tagging for BL manga follows the "yaoi for graphic sex, shounen-ai for no sex or merely implied sex", so I don't see why it shouldn't be applicable to GL.
You must be registered to post!
