manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
How big of a manga fan are you (in terms of # of series read / reading)?
Beginner (<10)
Casual reader (10-100)
Rookie (100-250)
Intermediate amateur (250-500)
Amateur (500-750)
Advanced amateur (750-1k)
Intermediate professional (1-1.5k)
Professional (1.5k-2k)
Advanced professional (2k-3k)
Sensei (3k+)
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

is hoshi wa utau better than furuba?

Back to Hoshi wa Utau


Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
freko_frika
Post #133868
Member

3:25 am, Mar 4 2008
Posts: 72


i'm just wondering about the public opinion, smile wink grin
well i've just started reading hoshi wa utau and i do like it...but i cant help but point out that the storyline might ended up being typical unlike fruits basket of course with the sohma curse and all..
what do you guys think?

funkmu1
Post #133871
user avatar
Member

3:27 am, Mar 4 2008
Posts: 2009


didnt like fruits basket at all, dunno about the hoshi wa utau thing tho. U might say that's cuz im a guy, but i happen to have read and read a lot of shojo manga, and I just thought fruits basket was kinda dumb. Mainly cuz i HATED the main character, and since i'm not attracted to any part of the bishies in the story, the entire story just fell flat for me. Gave up after like 5 volumes.

NightSwan
Post #157291
user avatar
Mad With a Hat
Member

3:58 pm, Apr 28 2008
Posts: 4583


Those are two different manga..
Written by the same mangaka..
Differend consepts ,characters and plotline.

I loved fruits basket, it's my favorite shoujo (and I don't like most shoujo..).
"Hoshi wa utau" is good, lookes nice and cute.
The art is better comapring with the first volumes of furuba.

Yes, maybe it's not as original as "Fruits Basket", but it's still has sweetness, and a good, and quite unique plot for a shoujo manga.

________________
Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
User Posted Image
And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.


Save your files!

If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.
freko_frika
Post #158337
Member

7:59 am, May 3 2008
Posts: 72


yeah now that ive read till chapter 17,i think hoshi wa utau is actually quite good..i mean there's the mysteriousnes bout chihiro,cant wait to find out! smile wink grin
and the art is really good!!
same here,cant tolerate bad art..
oh yeah,people shouldnt compare hoshi wa utau with furuba...
ah kanade.... ;)

Rinnie
Post #198965
user avatar
Member

10:57 am, Sep 5 2008
Posts: 4


I love Furuba, this Hoshi wa Utau somehow reminds me to it. But Hoshi wa Utau is also very wonderful, about the characters: not perfect, not all good-looking, has dark past [ Sakuya].
Those two manga are different, but somehow I see Tohru in Sakuya.


________________
Not change...
freko_frika
Post #201949
Member

3:41 pm, Sep 13 2008
Posts: 72


the plot in this manga just keeps getting intriguing by the minute.now there's a new character to watch out for.we dont know his name yet...

oh yeah the art in hoshi wa utau even though its the same in the later volumes of furuba is a lot more better if compared to the other.its beautiful and dark in the same time,if you get what i mean that is..

-i should really sleep- biggrin

tingster7
Post #207325
user avatar
Member

1:54 am, Sep 26 2008
Posts: 10


I looooved furuba! it was so good, yet so emotional! i cried so much! it's the same with hoshi wa utau. I love it too! Just as much. But i'm kinda glad that Sakuya isn't fully like Tohru. Tohru was awesome, but she never really showed when she was down, unlike Sakuya. I like people who aren't always perfect. But nevertheless, i love both of the mangas equally! smile

________________
Manga is my Life!
kippy666
Post #242632
Member

11:45 am, Dec 30 2008
Posts: 50


i think fruits basket is a really good manga and i love it to bits.
hoshi wa utau looks really good at the moment ive read all the chapters for it so far.
i wouldnt say its better though. I thought the charaters are good and none of them annoy me (which is always a good thing with any manga) and the plot is really interesting...just thinking about it i want to know what happens next.

when it comes to compareing manga im not the best.

anyway there no point asking if a manga is better if its still early in the story...

________________
claire here having some manga loving fun!
whatever that means....
freko_frika
Post #244270
Member

1:26 pm, Jan 3 2009
Posts: 72


i dont want to pin hoshi wa utau on furuba though.two very different mangas.but in beginning wise,Furuba had more comedy than hoshi wa utau.the plot in hoshi wa utau right frm the beginning is depressing and melancholic unlike in furuba.there's not much humour in Hoshi wa Utau..which is why i take it as an interesting manga.both manga's are nice in their own way.
perhaps it's a lil too early to compare the manga's.i just wished that hoshi wa utau will be as popular as furuba..haha

biggrin

catandmouse
Post #265111
user avatar
Member

7:55 am, Mar 8 2009
Posts: 410


I wouldn't say "better" cus they are different, but i would say that for a while I liked HwU more than I did Furuba, but now that has reversed and I found a new-found fondness for Furuba that i had somehow lost along the way...
I liked the "unrequited love" theme and for a while it seemed that way, but now i'm not too sure, I mean Chihiro has been warming up to Saku a lot, even though we can;t say for sure what's goign on..all I know is that if somehow Yuuri ends up like another version of Momiji, i'll be greatly disappointed....

freko_frika
Post #269548
Member

2:33 am, Mar 22 2009
Posts: 72


i surely hope not...even though the main plot revolves around unrequieted love. Yuuri is so cute eh...not that Chihiro isnt hot..haha
anyways whatever the outcome of the manga is,i'm sure it will be a blast..crosses finger.



ehime
Post #269555
user avatar
Member

3:09 am, Mar 22 2009
Posts: 42


While I did really like Furuba, I'm really getting into HwU. Both have very dark story elements and lovely art that kept my attention. Furuba started to bug me towards the end of the series though, so I hope that HwU won't disappoint!

catandmouse
Post #269961 - Reply to (#269555) by ehime
user avatar
Member

4:49 am, Mar 23 2009
Posts: 410


Quote from ehime
While I did really like Furuba, I'm really getting into HwU. Both have very dark story elements and lovely art that kept my attention. Furuba started to bug me towards the end of the series though, so I hope that HwU won't disappoint!


LOL..yeha that was what happeend to me and Furuba, towards the end it started to beother me, but then I have re-read the end and somehow that uneasiness has left me, and I was instantly hooked HwU, but as of late the story seems to go in a direction im not sure i like and and i'm really hoping that it wont dissapoint...

---nica
Post #269974
user avatar
Sorinozuka
Member

5:22 am, Mar 23 2009
Posts: 320


I know for a fact that I LOVE Takaya Natsuki.
Of course, Hoshi wa Utau would remind me of Furuba... but I still think Furuba is the best. (I might be biased since Furuba is my no. 1)
The dark atmosphere of Chihiro makes me wonder who he really is, and how he's connected to Sakuya and stuff.

________________
Want more of your favourite Intercross projects? Join Intercross as a staff member!
freko_frika
Post #271357
Member

5:22 pm, Mar 28 2009
Posts: 72


if uve read the current chapters ull know how they r connected.

the plot is sad yet charming in its own ways...but i guess i love both manga equally.in furuba i was cheering for kyo,but in hoshi wa utau my fav character is kanade even though he's just sakuya's guardian and is not her love interest nor he has nay romantic feelings for her...
aih...yeah im just rambling,aside from that my cheer goes to Yuuri coz he deserves Sakuya.

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to Hoshi wa Utau  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer