manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
App
Try out our new iPhone application!
App
Manga Poll
Demographic you read the most?
Shounen
Shoujo
Seinen
Josei
Shoujo Ai
Shounen Ai
Hentai
Lolicon
Shotacon
Yaoi
Yuri
 
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net

RSS Feed
 
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Ai in shounen?Shounen ai?

Back to Shounen/Seinen


You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
spareadress
Post #628812
user avatar
Hello
 Member

12:49 pm, Jan 17 2014
Posts: 23


i think the people who read shounen really would be turned off the Anime or manga no matter how good if it had Shounen Ai don't you think? because i think if naruto had Shounen ai between naruto and saskue ( i think that's how you spell it ? ah who cares biggrin) Some people would just change Anime . another Example is between Luffy and Zoro ( ugh that would be gross ) people would be turned off watching/reading it. One thing I've been thinking while writing this is that if you don't like gay love in general like your against gay people i don't understand this but i need to find out the answer or i'll go insane.

________________
She will never die but live on forever and she will wait but no-one will ever come. You cannot share pain but only bring it through your suffering. Fear is something that is created when you anxiety is around. Life and death are not to far but in fact very close. You will be forgotten when you die.
BaeSooky
Post #628821
user avatar
Monkey. :B
 Member

2:15 pm, Jan 17 2014
Posts: 1910


Yup, pretty sure they wouldn't read or watch it but that's assuming there really is shounen-ai. Those examples you gave fall under subtext. I take shounen-ai as being explicit, like a kiss or cuddling or whatever. XD

But see, I read both and I would be turned off too. The shounenish shounen-ais I've read have all made the characters really girly-looking.I read my shounen to get my shounen fix, and my shounen-ai to get my shounen-ai. If I wanted the best of both worlds I'd read djs or webcomics. laugh

I can't even think of a good example of a real shounen with some real shounen-ai that is also good in quality.

________________
User Posted Image
~Swannie-approved~ | Avy credit: Starry
Just your friendly neighborhood Monkey. Never play with your bananas! :B
dalek
Post #628860
user avatar
grrrrrrrrl
Member

7:20 pm, Jan 17 2014
Posts: 889


I wouldn't mind to see shounen-ai inside of a "shounenish" story, a example of anime like that was NO.6, I remember reading in the MAL forums that a lot of people dropped it after
Spoiler (mouse over to view)
a kissing scene between Shion and Nezumi.
But I don't really think NO.6 falls under "shounen-ai" either, but only seeing two protagonists doing that made some people dislike the anime... Since it is probably like BaeSooky said, "I read my shounen to get my shounen fix, and my shounen-ai to get my shounen-ai." So if you read a story that you don't even imagine two people being a couple, kissing etc, because it is out of character and only works good in djs (that somehow take the shounen feeling away), many would dislike reading shounen-ai scenes, even though they are okay with "gay love" in real life. There is also those who are totally against it too, be it fiction or real life, and would drop the manga/anime.

I think it is totally normal to be against a couple in a shounen manga and be okay with shounen-ai etc. It is like when I read yaoi manga, if I don't like where the story is going and don't want to see they together as a couple, it isn't because I'm against gay couples, but because I don't like that two characters as a couple. Same goes for those who don't like Luffy and Zoro, like you said, because you just don't like to see them as a couple. We have the same situation in both genres (shounen and yaoi), so I don't think it is homophobic to be against the idea of certain characters having a homosexual relationship in a shounen manga.

I don't know if I answered your question or just blabbed lots of non-related stuff.

TL;DR: there are those who are totally against "gay love" in real life of fiction, but also those who wouldn't like to see two characters from the same sex being lovey-dovey in shounen manga because it is out of character, "they don't have chemistry" or simply because it would lead the story to a unpleasant way.

________________
:: myanimelist :: avatar credits ::
Shonaiula
Post #628864 - Reply to (#628821) by BaeSooky
user avatar
Member

8:20 pm, Jan 17 2014
Posts: 95


Quote from BaeSooky
I read my shounen to get my shounen fix, and my shounen-ai to get my shounen-ai.

I think this sums the whole thing up pretty well.

To expand on it, I wouldn't particularly like to see shounen-ai in a shounen manga because it'll add an additional factor to the story that I feel doesn't really fit. Like if you're baking a chocolate cake and add in... pepper. The taste will be off, and honestly kinda weird. How shounen-ai is received depends more on where and how it is portrayed rather than whether the reader likes actually likes shounen-ai or not.

A prime example would be the 2013 anime K. I love the setting, art, characters and the entire set up in whole... but the "almost shounen-ai but not shounen-ai of two guys staring at each other" scenes made me cringe. It was absolutely awkward. I felt like the creators were trying too hard with the fanservice, you know? It's something that doesn't contribute at all to the actual story, it's just... there. That said, it didn't turn me off the anime (looking forward to the movie *grins*), but then again I have the convenient ability to ignore things I don't like. XD Kinda just skipped over those scenes and half erased them from my memory. I have seen many complaints around the net about it though.

So for me it would be the context. If the shounen-ai actually was tied into the plot and with good consistent development from the start, I would be okay with it. But if its just out of nowhere and serves no purpose, I would definitely say that the series would be better without it.

________________
MY TOP THREE MANGA OF ALL TIME <3
Kuroshitsuji
Pandora Hearts
Akagami no Shirayukihime
monkry
Post #629497
user avatar
Mongrels
Member

10:39 am, Jan 22 2014
Posts: 137


Despise it. I read shounen not to find shounen-ai none
People can freely express it in doujin, but please don't put shounen-ai in a title with shounen genre...
I truly do not hope to see shounen-ai there...

Well... I don't think there's 'shounen-ai' in real Naruto's manga...
maybe the term is... bromance? biggrin
haha I read in a funny site, there's a post that more or less stated this:
"You're not real friend till people think you're gay" laugh

15: Meisetsu Kougyou Koukou Rugby-Bu
this title is shounen. But IMO the fanservice is too... harsh... for a shounen reader that's searching for shounen... If it's being put in shoujo or josei, maybe it'll be popular, but to put it in shounen... hnggg... I think the problem is the some scenes are represented in a very shounen-ai context...

________________
User Posted Image
You must be registered to post!

Back to Shounen/Seinen  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
 
Manga Search
MANGA Fu
MEMBERS
TEAM-BU


footer