| From User |
Message Body |
|
Indreju
|
Post #53992 |
Super Mod
3:36 pm, Sep 15 2007
Posts: 1325
|
Filter.
If there are people who think incest is wrong/disgusting or the exact opposite, fun/interesting, why not allow them to have the chance to choose whatever they like?After all, it's an information site. For some of people who visit MU, this type of information is probably important.
And how to handle incest or not incest problem...I would say to label it as incest even if it's about a relationship between step siblings, cause the whole situation in which they are seems like an incest for most of the other characters. People may want to/don't want to read something with incest or just about it (then it doesn't even matter if it really is an incest or not)
I can't explain it right, don't bite me.
________________
Still the bad cop. |
|
Stealth
|
Post #54028 |
Site Admin
5:19 pm, Sep 15 2007
Posts: 1036
|
I say no...
No need for that. Seriously, 99.99% of the time you have enough information in the title, series description and the scanlators site to tell. And... euh, just don't read hentai if you're offended by :
- Rape
- Incest
- Tentacles
- underage sex
- zoophilia
- etc...
And if you're going to start with these stuff, we're in for a lot more trouble. I mean, we'd eventually have to filter Guro because people are offended by it...
And then some people find manga involving angels/demons and stuff religiously offensive and then who knows what else some people can find offensive...
Actually, in short? I agree with NeoFireHawk. (euh and I think Kraust too).
________________
So predictable... |
|
lambchopsil
|
Post #121405 |
Archon Solon
2:45 am, Feb 9 2008
Posts: 7188
|
Revived again in: http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=3889
Our answer still: No
________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
lambchopsil---
MangaUpdates admin
Join the MangaUpdates Folding@Home team! (and help humanity)
Click here for info. Easy signup |
|
Nomad
|
Post #124668 |
Member
12:58 pm, Feb 16 2008
Posts: 37
|
How can you have lolita, gay manga, but not incest? 
|
|
ippy
|
Post #124963 - Reply to ( #124668) by Nomad |
Member
3:17 am, Feb 17 2008
Posts: 106
|
Quote from Nomad How can you have lolita, gay manga, but not incest?
gay manga is categorized in japan already, and it's a big category. incest manga probably aren't (not sure) and it's not as big of a category, especially since most manga don't completely center on that while the gay ones do.
|
|
shi666san
|
Post #124964 |
Here for the lulz
Member
3:20 am, Feb 17 2008
Posts: 778
|
I would like to see "incest", you know? well, since i do like h manga
________________
~Diddle~
Taste the Beat
 |
|
Nomad
|
Post #124978 - Reply to ( #124963) by ippy |
Member
3:39 am, Feb 17 2008
Posts: 37
|
Quote from ippy Quote from Nomad How can you have lolita, gay manga, but not incest? gay manga is categorized in japan already, and it's a big category. incest manga probably aren't (not sure) and it's not as big of a category, especially since most manga don't completely center on that while the gay ones do.
This website =/= japan/general public
Would it hurt to gather Manga that center around incest and put it onto that genre?
|
|
Dr. Love
|
Post #125133 |
Nbl. Rushy
Member
9:59 am, Feb 17 2008
Posts: 8737
|
The people who want to have 'Incest' as a genre, haven't you read the whole thread? There are plenty of arguments why it should not be implemented as a genre.
Edit: Or can't you at least see above your post? Two site admins already said; "No"...
________________
source: animenewsnetwork
Join SRoMU Scanlations or visit #SRoMU at IRCHighWay. |
|
Indreju
|
Post #125138 |
Super Mod
10:25 am, Feb 17 2008
Posts: 1325
|
Here "no" usually means no
Well, there was a suggestion to add key words to manga. That could allow you find/filter out incest. Well, this suggestion was ignored and I don't see any more ways to do what you're asking for.
________________
Still the bad cop. |
|
Pomegranate
|
Post #126268 |
Member
2:38 am, Feb 19 2008
Posts: 288
|
I wouldn't care either way, but I think that it'd be too much work on our already (very) crowded genre selection. If we add incest, we'd have to add rape and other weird love sub-genres.
And besides, is there even enough incest to make an entire new genre for it? Most of the incest out there already implies it in the summary.
________________
"Mah...Mah..." - Creampan
 |
|
HeavennevaeH
|
Post #130046 |
Lurker Queen.
Member
6:32 pm, Feb 26 2008
Posts: 779
|
I agree completely to Indreju. Filtering keywords (like the reverse of searching for them) would be a brilliant idea!  and if it's minor it could be said in the synopsis "warning: some incest". So the genre wouldn't be altered or over-loaded and people will be able to avoid it 
|
|
ashimaruyfg
|
Post #198562 - Reply to ( #8491) by Laclongquan |
Member
1:40 am, Sep 4 2008
Posts: 2
|
Quote from Laclongquan And the last words: usually guys did that kind of manga also say something about the content. As far as I remember, there;s no incest manga without some kind of description telling you that.
Well the thing is that I think Incest should be a genre mostly because, personally, after opening the title for a discription, it sort of turns my stomach read or even seeing the manga cover.
|
|
Rainy Days
|
Post #198566 |
it's a boy
Member
2:03 am, Sep 4 2008
Posts: 2877
|
I'd prefer incest over yaoi/yuri anyday.
|
|
Identity Crisis
|
Post #198573 |
Super Mod
2:30 am, Sep 4 2008
Posts: 4870
|
i'd like that option, so i can find incest more easily...
|
|
elenaluz
|
Post #203704 |
Member
11:10 am, Sep 17 2008
Posts: 7
|
Heh. So many people here seem to equate incest w/ hentai. Haven't you heard of Ed x Al, or the twins in Ouran? Incest is rampant in yaoi/yuri, too. 
I didn't even realize there wasn't a genre for rape/non-con, until Pomegranate pointed out its lack. Yeah, I just remembered that rape/non-con is rampant in yaoi/yuri, too.
Personally, I wouldn't mind seeing a genre for both of these, but since two admins have already said no, that's probably out of the question. I don't really care about reading about it or seeing the image, but it would save me some time when I'm browsing for new things to read.
|
