the other guy was extremely nicer and better than the main dude. main dude was pretty much a abusive, stalking, "lets solve you going out with my slave with violence," character. terrible. girl is retarded too, its like a wife who is abused by her husband to one day accept the fact that her husband is only abusing her because he wants to monopolize her and loves her and as a result, fall in love. in fact its worse because they arent dating at all.

This One Shot is… not recommended.

Plot- Nothing really new in the plot, it’s a bit of a recycled one and I was prepared for it to follow the normal clichés… which it did.

Characters- … I disliked them… a lot… Yui is very weak willed and can’t seem to just stand up for herself! Aya was quite abusive and didn’t seem to care at all for Yui; both he and her sister only seemed to be using Yui. No one had any redeeming qualities…

Art- Fine I guess, nothing special but it wasn’t bad either.

Other- There are some fluffy moments that may make you go “Aww…” by themselves these moments are sweet but in a whole when added to the rest of the story and with the stories characters these moments loose their charm. This story isn’t good, shadowed by unlikable characters and an annoying conclusion.

2/10 –Didn’t like it

I decided to read this because the author is the same as the one of Shugaku Ryoko - Naisho no Koi which was okay(the hero was nice and cute) and I was in the mood for more shoujo oneshots.

This was just...it made me rethink reading the rest of the mangaka's works. I mean, what is up with the characters?! I don't think the author was going for anything remotely similar to sadomachoism but this is how the manga comes off as, don't get me wrong, I like the occassional BDSM but this just sucked.

Page after page, the interactions between the 'lead' characters were just cringe-worthy(except Yoshida, he was the only one that I didn't hate which says a lot about this).

This was just pushing the "good guys don't get the girl" trope too too much. I like the incorporation of male leads getting jealous in some/most manga but this was just borderline abusive, actually, what am I saying? It is abusive, the way the a**hole treats the girl(the events near the end does little to redeem him).

Sorry. I think my being critical mostly stems from my disappointment at this author.

The supposed male lead? I can't even call him a hero(male leads in romance). I kept seeing him as the antagonist that Yoshida-kun had to save the female lead from. Really...I might, *might* have forgiven him a little if the mangaka did the typical thing and made Yoshida two-faced so it was clear who the female lead was going to end up with.

Douchebaggery...totally agree with mango123. Despite Aya's a**holery, I couldn't feel anything for the heroine other than pity and "whaddahellgurl?!?"

The page where the guy is supposed to look blush-worthy? He just looks constipated. Yoshida's the kind and simple type but I'd totally take him over Aya any day even though I like jerk/tsundere guys sometimes. (Aya was neither, he's a class A douche bag.)

If it had been a bit longer, maybe the male lead would have had time to redeem himself in the eyes of the reader. Maybe. We'll never know.

... Last updated on July 22nd, 2012, 3:02am

This is a warning.
Do not read this manga.
It is utter crap.
I guessed the ending by the 4th page.
I wont spoil what is already disgusting and rotted.
Im just telling you. Do not read this.
For your own sanity.

eh, ya was supposed to be Romance, but the focus from beginning to mid end to much on her and some other dude, that the main dude did not get all the amount of lovely dovely till the end.. but its was ok, and if u think ahead of life ....

It was extremely rushed, I`m not kidding.
So because of that there wasn`t any chance of carachter developpement so the whole story wasn't as captivating (although I sticked with it hopeing something will pop up)
Basically what happens in the beginning is the guy is a completly abusive type carachter because he's all violent and possesive... the other guy is WAY nicer (this difference is possibly the mangaka's way to make readers sympathize with the other guy)


So to say the least, I was hope-ing this was going to be like moe kare considering the main guy is a male tsundere but his complete change of carachter (without any subtle hints) is pretty bad...

so I'm not bothering to rate this, it could've had more

the sister had potential too but she isn't important besides saving her sister from being umm...

anyways: (I think the reason for the title is because the main dude is younger than the main girl and so her relationship with him is more sibling like... what if this was supposidly meant to be incest?)

... Last updated on February 3rd, 2011, 8:28pm

Really! This is not really that Bad...
With Weak and Clumsy female lead + Sadist-Violent not-Honest male lead, it's annoying but Cute!
Don't mean to praise or ridicule this manga, but this is the reality of this manga!

... Last updated on March 3rd, 2012, 12:56am