Oh yeah, long post ahead...
Quote from bully_jesus
Quote
The problem is that most people rarely rate the manga they read, and less write a comment about it...
True for some manga, but i would say that there are enough votes to get a decent rating.
However, voting really isn't much work. In the list of mangas you read you can really quickly give each a vote.
I think it's got to be people are lazy. IMDB has lots, and lots of members. I don't know how many people vote but I think the number is low. I don't think I've voted on any or at least 99.99% of the titles that I have on My Movie list. :x I think this might be due somewhat to the real-life North American voting mentality--"why does my vote matter". xD :x And somehow, I guess I hesitate to put a number/rating on the manga I read. I can't immediately pick a rating once I'm finished a manga because I think it takes a while for the ending to sink in. And if the ending isn't enough for me, that's even more true. I can re-rate but...I guess that comes down to being a chicken and I don't like giving an unfair rating even if it's only temporary. And there's some laziness in there too. This would go into a "why don't you rate manga you read?" topic if it existed. And maybe the sad part of that topic would be that people would spend more time making excuses rather than rate their manga. But Then again, I guess I sort of remember about how *I* mentally rated most manga I read provided the manga wasn't completely unforgotteable.
AMV.org ended up putting quick comments in for when people download an AMV the person has to leave some kind of comment. It's not as good as a long review and there's some "fluff" comments (comments like "I stole your soul", although those might have been jokes between friends on the site). Maybe as much as I might not like it myself, if we mark a manga as "complete" on our manga lists, we have to rate it to put it on the Complete List. It's payment for having your lists on the site! >D It would be even more work for a person building up his or her manga lists from nothing but... *rubs hands evilly*
I sort of wish I could just throw the database part of Manga-Updates into Google and just look for manga that I want. But I think looking for manga with the mention of "model" in their summary is like using Google Images. I don't know why Google isn't better at searching Manga-Updates even though I think the site is 1 or 2 years old? There are probably a fair amount of manga series entries that would be around that time due to the administrators adding a good amount of them (I think lambchopsil, Manick, mallow(sp? Gomen if I did x[) added about a 1000 series). But I wonder if all the minor updating of the pages affects whether Google searches the page. Or maybe Google likes ignoring us because they would rather have their search engine sort Wikipedia.
If we keep dicussion this way though, either a new topic has to be started or one of the currents have to be picked for dicussion to "move" to.
[quote=luisalirio84]...(the quote function wouldn't work for his name here ...I couldn't even apply italics to the text...?! O_o)
B-b-b-b-ut... Life is no fun without a little flame every now and then. Soo boring. Fine . I apologize to you sincerely mr. rillel [/quote]
Even if that comment about the flaming was a joke luisalirio, I remember when Kaioh made comments about your post count in the Manga-Updates facts and I can't help but think along with your reply in that thread, you also used about half or more of one of your posts in the Your Age (not a repeat topic) thread (which I know I hold a bit of bitterness about) venting about it.
I also feel you're also using rillel's or this thread as a scrapegoat for your anger about the recommendation manga threads. I'm sure if this had been the 5th recommendation instead of closer to the 20th of its kind, I would hope you wouldn't be as hard on this guy. Since you're saying to wait for the recommendation feature to come into place, aren't you indirectly complaining about Manick to hurry up with it, since (I believe) he's building it? Besides, we don't know how "soon" (or when) it will come out (I'm not saying for Manick to hurry up. I don't expect the recommendation feature to fix all the "recommending" problems).
Edit:
Quote from luisalirio84
Rillel how can one get to be as annoying as you ? I'd really like to know
If it was the part of "thanks for the flaming/help" well, I don't consider it any worse that you calling him "annoying" and yet I know that to you're not always a picnic in the park, luisalirio.
Quote from luisalirio84
Also why is this thread still open people reccommended plenty of series to the guy What is it open for future generations to reccommend stuff to him as well ? I 'll reccommend something so as to not get in trouble ... hmm... go read ... Nodame Cantabile ... and Yamada Tarou and Kami no Shizuku
If you want a thread locked, if might be better to PM an admin if you think it was pressing (I think it's fair that along with lambchopsil's statement about Manick that the admin doesn't read every post or pick the posts apart in their daily routines). But I think the admins give us some freedom sometimes for things to recover even things get heated (I think there's proof in the first part of this thread) or decided it's still relevant or the thread is redeemable sometimes.
Last edited by Takiko at 9:38 pm, Jun 14 2007
________________
My avatar was Yves Saint Laurent's The Black Evening Dress (with big bow) first shown in 1983, photographed from his 2002 retrospective and final show. [color=#CC0066]Check out some of his collections for free (pre-2008) HERE[/color] courtesy of FirstView.