banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Your favourite manga with a lower MU rating?

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Member

9:01 pm, Jun 28 2012
Posts: 236


Is there a manga that you love and would rate highly, that you think has a surprisingly low rating on this site?

Yes, this is completely subjective. But if it surprised you, then it qualifies.

With the user ratings being so visible on lists now, I got curious. Plus I'm always looking for good manga to read smile




My ones would be;

7.75 Hakuji Pretty art, really pretty art, and sweet angst are the main attractions of this one. But the story is memorable enough that I expected a better rating.
7.90 Biyaku Cafe I'm not saying this one is perfect, but I think a lot of the reviews are after the first chapter. The Expresso chapters made me cry. And I personally quite like the first main couple.

Yeah, none of these are super low rated, but anyways.

Post #558670
user avatar
Member

3:06 am, Jun 29 2012
Posts: 197


These mangas are not my absolute favorites, but i really enjoyed them for all they had to offer, so i gave them both 9.

Yeah i was a little shocked when i found out that

Nanase was at 7.55 - it's not that bad, but it was good, had nice art and characters.

Blue was at 7.22 - it was one of the best slice of life stories i've read this year.

They aren't super low, but i still expected them to fare better. And these are the only ones i can point my finger to, i'm very strict with my ratings.

Member

7:37 am, Jul 3 2012
Posts: 1041


Kinnikuman its one of the funniest shounen mangas ever...with a rating of 6.5...idiots

Remote cute girl,smart hikikomori lead,crime solving and only 7.1

Vector Case File - Inaho no Konchuuki very funny and only 6.6

Wrestle! Idol extreme wrestling...lol deserve better than 6.6





user avatar
Member

7:39 am, Jul 3 2012
Posts: 389


You know all my favorite manga are yaoi, and for some reason, yaoi tends to have very high ratings ^-^

But Tsuugaku Densha - Kimi to Boku no Heya Is such a good shoujo manga with only a rating of 7.2

________________
*Wonders How To Post A Picture*
You must be registered to post!