banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Clarification on Astor's comment

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Post #393874
user avatar
rawr
Member

12:09 am, Jul 24 2010
Posts: 161


Quote
this manhwa has no publisher by Astor on July 22nd, 2010, 7:22pm

art is pretty and story is cute but no major plot has yet been introduced...
this manhwa has no publisher since it's updated at a popular forum where people submit their web comics to get scouted by publishers... so this isn't an official manhwa. i was disappointed when the story had to start all over again because story writer dropped out of project

I wish Astor made a forum post and not a comment so I could have just replied... lol anyways.

It's published on Naver, thus it's rather incorrect to say that it has no publisher. It does not need to be printed to say it has a publisher. But, it's considered a "challenge" manhwa, meaning it's trying to get into the Naver's mainline webtoon. It is also neither a forum and while most are probably looking to be scouted, they rarely are. So, it's hard to say that's the reason it's being made. Maybe they just like to make these things. And I don't think there's a line where "official" manhwa starts...

Also, story writer did NOT drop out of the project. The author simple chose to deviate into a different story.

________________
The Company
[b]Batoto
Post #448748 - Reply to (#393874) by Grumpy
user avatar
Member

10:14 pm, Feb 21 2011
Posts: 339


Quote from Grumpy
Also, story writer did NOT drop out of the project. The author simple chose to deviate into a different story.


Could you expand on this? I don't quite understand what happened either. confused

Post #448754
user avatar
Site Admin

10:38 pm, Feb 21 2011
Posts: 2275


I don't know what's up with the whole author thing. BUT he/she/it is no longer with the story according to the scanlators.

The artist's the same. So, he/she/it probably choose to do the deviating, or simply choose to go with whatever new author gave him/her/it.


As for "is it published," if the creators were paid... then it's published. However, from what the scanlators are saying, this series isn't published... Unfortunately, the other series is (I still don't think Naver should be considered a publisher though).

________________
"Officially, this machine doesn't exist, you didn't get it from me,
and I don't know you. Make sure it doesn't leave the building."
user avatar
Member

12:40 pm, Feb 27 2011
Posts: 23


So if I understand this whole thing right, we won't see chapter 22?

________________
Get revenge - sh!t on a pigeon!
Post #451874
Member

2:41 am, Mar 7 2011
Posts: 1


sounds like the jest of it >.>

Post #456059 - Reply to (#451874) by denero1
user avatar
Member

2:58 pm, Mar 23 2011
Posts: 23


Quote from denero1
sounds like the jest of it >.>


Uh. This sentence could mean several things, depending on where you built in the mistake.

Did you mean "gist" instead of "jest"? "Sounds like that's the gist of it."

Or did you want to say, that the whole thing is one big joke?
"Sounds like one big jest."

...

________________
Get revenge - sh!t on a pigeon!
Post #456083
user avatar
Site Admin

4:19 pm, Mar 23 2011
Posts: 2275


Well, even if the group wanted to do it... they can't unless they already had the chapters collected. This is because all chapters have been removed from the naver... daum website.

________________
"Officially, this machine doesn't exist, you didn't get it from me,
and I don't know you. Make sure it doesn't leave the building."
You must be registered to post!