banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

Regarding tags with Shoujo/Josei Isekai Manhwa

You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
user avatar
Site Admin

6:39 pm, Nov 1 2022
Posts: 59


Someone had brought this up and I agree. Lately I been looking at the tags/categories and I feel like may people don't know the difference between Transmigrated/Transmigration, Reincarnated/Reincarnation and Transported/Transportation. So I see many repetitive tags going on.

●Transmigrated/Transmigration = When a soul is moved or enters a body that isn't there's (most times after their own death)

●Reincarnated/Reincarnation = When a soul is reborn/rebirth, meaning they are completely born into a body that is now there's

●Transported/Transportation = When said person, in there own body, is transported in a world that isn't there's.


Majority of the Shoujo and Josei Manhwa series are Transmigration not Reincarnation. I want fix the tagging system with this kind of series but I want see what you all think because I know there are series within this gerne that later on reveal that the Main Character is a reincarnation.

Though there is a site that give spoilers to these, as most are based on novels, so we can avoid tagging it with the incorrect term

Example of Reincarnation Isekai is Daughter of the Emperor and Who Made Me a Princess

Example of a Transmigration Isekai is I Fell into a Reverse Harem Game!

Edit: And I know some of the summaries and synpois say reincarnation but doesn't mean it's correct. It's because Transmigration isn't well use, so they just use the term Reincarnation, which is more known

Also most of these series have the Historical gerne as well, I will be removing that gerne from the majority of them as it's not a Historical manhwa but just a Fantasy based on European attire

Last edited by Lovelyspacepanda at 11:53 pm, Nov 2 2022

user avatar


8:52 pm, Nov 1 2022
Posts: 10668


I'm fine with that

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
Post #799720 - Reply to (#799719) by lambchopsil
user avatar
Site Admin

10:48 pm, Nov 1 2022
Posts: 59


Quote from lambchopsil
I'm fine with that

Do you mean you're fine with how the tags are or do you mean you're fine with me trying to fix it?

I don't mind, I just want things be more accurate

Last edited by Lovelyspacepanda at 11:43 pm, Nov 1 2022

Post #799721
user avatar
Site Admin

12:19 am, Nov 2 2022
Posts: 168


Seconded, I'm fine that. Isn't that what it means? As long as we understand the use and know the context. I think this applies to other demographics as well.

Post #799722 - Reply to (#799720) by Lovelyspacepanda
user avatar


12:43 am, Nov 2 2022
Posts: 10668


Quote from Lovelyspacepanda
Do you mean you're fine with how the tags are or do you mean you're fine with me trying to fix it?

I don't mind, I just want things be more accurate

I'm fine with you trying to fix it

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
Post #799727
user avatar
Member

5:37 pm, Nov 2 2022
Posts: 23


Makes sense to fix it! I think if a series later shows that it's actually reincarnation or something, we can just use both tags for that manga?

You must be registered to post!