banner_jpg
Username/Email: Password:
Forums

ONEMANGA CLOSING D;<

Pages (15) [ First ... 12 13 14 15 ]  
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member

11:57 pm, Jul 23 2010
Posts: 8


I have posted a separate topic: http://www.mangaupdates.com/showtopic.php?tid=19930

I believe we need to protect our history and culture online. Please support the scanlation of unlicenced manga by boycotting American published manga! I myself have been a user of onemanga for 5-6 years, and found the message heartbreaking.

user avatar
jail bait
Member

12:09 am, Jul 24 2010
Posts: 1444


wHYYYYYYYYYY??!!!!!!
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!
<you dont have to answer the first sudden reaction>
awww... too bad really... online manga sites are closing?? then how am i suppose to read manga nowconfused the mangas that i want to read are not available here and i am not allowed to buy things online... seriously... this is bad... bad for my health.. my mental health... positivity!! postivity... posi-.. posi-... this is bad... really... really bad... none cry

________________
oh please do click this!
The sweeter the apple, the higher the branch. The quieter the fart, the nastier the smell.
GUESS WHO??
Post #393922 - Reply to (#393501) by thecg
user avatar
Member

4:47 am, Jul 24 2010
Posts: 56


Quote from thecg
And are you too dumb to e-mail either of these companies and maybe start a petition to get them to change? And bullshit 96% of the translations are bad, I can say the same for scanlations which are amateur translations done by fans. I find dozens of grammatical errors all over scans so don't even say they're perfect. Throwing random percentages out won't help your argument.

You can sit there and say what these companies do is wrong but complaining to a small community of fans and refusing to buy the translations doesn't send the message that you want better quality, it sends the message that you're too lazy to organize a movement and would much rather steal not only from the companies but from the creators themselves who get absolutely no money from scanlations at all.

So if you think you're being all righteous and fighting against the manga companies you're fooling yourself. You're hurting the creators just as much. If you're gonna bitch about quality get off your rear and actually do something about it, get together all the people who agree with you that the translations are terrible and have all of those people mail TP and Viz, they won't ignore the fans, or else they wouldn't make a profit.

And I must question when the last time you even bought a manga and read anything beyond Shonen Jump titles, because quality has gone way higher than it was in the early days. I honestly can't remember the last title I picked up that was horribly butchered beyond the ability to read it.


There were plenty of petitions but those retard think they do a good job. The las time I bought manga - a few years ago (they do not seel any manga in my country and imprting them is a real killer due to taxing fees so I can only get them when I go to germany or other place) last time I bought novel a month and a few weeks ago, not in english as I read it in Japanese but I have seen the published work and I have to say the majority sucks.

Maybe it is time for you to get out of your pink little world and see that the quality is not really increasing. You are just fooling yourself if you really think so.

Lets say the last Spice and Wolf novel release had plenty of spaces where it reeked of rewrite rather than a translation.

Sure not all grammar is correct in scalators works but at least they try to stay close to original without doing censorships or rewrites.

Why should I buy something which comes late and has less quality? More so that I can better buy original manga and support the author directly rather than these guys. Heck they know zero of Japanese culture and thats why they ,miss most of the jokes (you can see that very clearly in novels).

________________
Hobby:

Manga/Anime. Philosophy, Poetry, books, basketball, russian rock.
Post #393929
user avatar
Mome Basher
Member

5:42 am, Jul 24 2010
Posts: 3380


Maybe it's time for scanslation groups to go legit and show the current publishers how it's done bigrazz

________________
User Posted Image
Everyday I'm tumblin'
Post #393930 - Reply to (#393689) by Scyfon
Member

5:57 am, Jul 24 2010
Posts: 169


Quote from Scyfon
So the group of publishers, particularly the Japanese publishers, banded up to fight scanslation...just for fun?


It wasn't just for fun, but I would call it a misdirected effort. Most likely the English manga industry lead the charge by complaining that they could not make sales due to scans which is why Japanese publishers rallied together because they think there is potential to make more profit in the English market.

The push by publishers certainly wasn't spurred on by any harm to their sales at home. Japanese pirates have no need for English scans, there are easily obtainable RAWs all over the net.

So what effect will this have on the English market? It won't stop people from reading manga online, piracy is everywhere and will never disappear. For every one site they take down three rise to take its place. The only thing this will succeed in doing is souring peoples opinions of the industry.

The one advantage store bought manga has over online material is the physical hard copy. I've bought manga before when I wanted a hard copy of my favorite series. It's something I could take with me and read. It's something to do when the power goes out when we're hit by a hurricane.

These are the kind of sales they'll lose when they piss people off. You don't sell goods by crapping on your customer base.

Why should I buy manga when I know the profits they get from the sale will be used to fuel the lawyer machine and will come back to bite me in the ass in the future?

user avatar


7:26 am, Jul 24 2010
Posts: 10663


We are locking all such related threads because they are degenerating into flame wars

________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
Pages (15) [ First ... 12 13 14 15 ]  
You must be registered to post!