________________
D'oh!
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Forums
My Little Sister Can't Be This Cute
From User
Message Body
The Shorty
Member11:53 am, Sep 6 2010
Posts: 330
In this manga, is the romance incest or is it normal?
________________
D'oh!
________________
D'oh!
Member
8:38 am, Sep 12 2010
Posts: 748
uptill chapter 8 so far there has not been any romance between sister and brother. The only romance possible atm is between the brother and his friend(girl with glasses) though I can see that changing.
________________
Angel Beats--best anime of the 2010 spring season
________________
Angel Beats--best anime of the 2010 spring season
Member
7:14 am, Oct 5 2010
Posts: 6
I have noticed that after the translation of chapter 10 we see the translation of chapter 18. What happened to chapters 11-17? O_o I know the translations is being by different groups but still...
7:58 am, Oct 5 2010
Posts: 10663
No asking about translation status. Don't you notice that there's different groups doing this series?
________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
________________
A just ruler amongst tyrants
Member
7:38 am, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 302
7:38 am, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 302
most likely (if the manga follow the novel path) a deconstruction of wincest trope
Last edited by jasperv at 2:37 pm, Oct 31 2010
Quote
Pragmatic Adaptation: Originally a Light Novel series, the manga and anime adaptations take a very different approach to the material, with the manga cranking Up To Eleven the Fanservice, Male Gaze and Incest Yay from the novels, while the anime actually removes most of it. This often shows on fans coming from different media having very different views on the series.
ref tvtropes.comLast edited by jasperv at 2:37 pm, Oct 31 2010
Mome Basher
Member
1:04 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 3380
The Shorty
Member1:13 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 330
Quote from Scyfon
Nothing wrong with wincest...
there is! lol people are twisted by manga... geez normal people are HORRIFIED by incest
________________
D'oh!
Mome Basher
Member
1:16 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 3380
Quote from Masterba
Quote from Scyfon
Nothing wrong with wincest...
there is! lol people are twisted by manga... geez normal people are HORRIFIED by incest
No, I wouldn't call myself twisted.
Its just knowing to differentiate between real life and fiction.
Wincest is only a win in fiction, not in real life.
Last edited by Scyfon at 2:01 pm, Oct 31 2010
________________
Everyday I'm tumblin'
insomniac Kagehime
Member
1:16 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 2707
It isn´t
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
The Shorty
Member1:39 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 330
Quote from ShadowSakura
It isn´t
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
well i kind of agree with you since manga isnt real life and all but still... its kinda disturbing
________________
D'oh!
It's him!!
Member
2:03 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 617
Quote from Masterba
Quote from ShadowSakura
It isn´t
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
well i kind of agree with you since manga isnt real life and all but still... its kinda disturbing
I'd like to take this chance and state that there really isn't any rational moral argument against incest. Just because you feel like something is wrong or immoral, doesn't make it so. As long as you believe morality stems from rationality that is.
For example, I feel it's wrong for 45 year olds to have relationships with 18 year olds. That doesn't make it immoral, though there are certain social and practical issues.
on topic though; if I am not mistaken, it's going to be a while untill there are even hints of Kirino having romantic feelings for her brother. I believe the first signs were supposed to be in novel 6 or something.
________________
Do but despise reason and science,
The highest of all human gifts -
Then you have surrendered to the Devil
And must surely perish. - J.W. von Goethe
insomniac Kagehime
Member
2:06 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 2707
Quote from The Guy
Quote from Masterba
Quote from ShadowSakura
It isn´t
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
the title somehow screams for incest.I am really surpirsed there wasn´t any yet. I would like to see some -.-* manga incest is smexy, but real incest is not.
It is cute until now, maybe a bishie will appear and the brother notices that he is bad or something like that what could turn the relationship between those to into romance. But i don´t think it´ll go that way
well i kind of agree with you since manga isnt real life and all but still... its kinda disturbing
I'd like to take this chance and state that there really isn't any rational moral argument against incest. Just because you feel like something is wrong or immoral, doesn't make it so. As long as you believe morality stems from rationality that is.
For example, I feel it's wrong for 45 year olds to have relationships with 18 year olds. That doesn't make it immoral, though there are certain social and practical issues.
on topic though; if I am not mistaken, it's going to be a while untill there are even hints of Kirino having romantic feelings for her brother. I believe the first signs were supposed to be in novel 6 or something.
it hasn´t anything to do with immorality but if the higher rate of genetic defects. But sibling incest isn´t that bad, just if it´s parent child. Also there are enough other people in this wolrd (i know that love isn´t predictable). And the huge age gap couples are just disgusting.
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
Is a female
Member2:20 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 3457
Can we not discuss the morality of Incest in here as well? I can see debates/discussions in the making.
Seriously, we've got this thread and this thread for that.
Anyway, the title screams incest. I can see it happening.
I think I remember reading somewhere that a relationship does develop between the two anyway. I think it was mentioning the light novel though. Dunno whether they'll include it in the manga and anime.
Seriously, we've got this thread and this thread for that.
Anyway, the title screams incest. I can see it happening.
I think I remember reading somewhere that a relationship does develop between the two anyway. I think it was mentioning the light novel though. Dunno whether they'll include it in the manga and anime.
Spoiler (highlight to view)
They'd better.
insomniac Kagehime
Member
2:22 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 2707
Quote from tactics
Can we not discuss the morality of Incest in here as well? I can see debates/discussions in the making.
Seriously, we've got this thread and this thread for that.
Anyway, the title screams incest. I can see it happening.
I think I remember reading somewhere that a relationship does develop between the two anyway. I think it was mentioning the light novel though. Dunno whether they'll include it in the manga and anime.
Seriously, we've got this thread and this thread for that.
Anyway, the title screams incest. I can see it happening.
I think I remember reading somewhere that a relationship does develop between the two anyway. I think it was mentioning the light novel though. Dunno whether they'll include it in the manga and anime.
Spoiler (highlight to view)
They'd better.
but sadly i think if they wanted to do that they would have made it an ova
but if seen some doujin were it happened^^
________________
currently reading: Nyotai-ka
please support me
Is a female
Member2:28 pm, Oct 31 2010
Posts: 3457
Yeah I've seen those as well.
Doujins mean nothing though, you know that
They might include elements of it in the anime, you never know. It does air late at 11:30pm in Japan so maybe. *shrugs*
Doujins mean nothing though, you know that
They might include elements of it in the anime, you never know. It does air late at 11:30pm in Japan so maybe. *shrugs*
