Idea from the thread: Ecchi: Yay or Nay?

Curious to see how many shoujo fans like smut. O_O I don't particularly like it, have read a few and they were all bad IMO. Focused too much on the smut and not enough on the plot, but I guess that's the point? @_@;;

But I do love YOSHIHARA Yuki's work...+~+

Well yeah, nay from me. xD

________________

Monkeys, always at your service.

I don't like it, or the way it's usually applied, the randomness of when the love-making begins is almost as bad as hentai, just ruins the flow of the story. In the right situations, sex could improve the story, but I've yet to see one where it's been pulled off really nicely.

Ehhh, there should be a "sometimes" option.

"Sometimes" I enjoy it, when it's part of the plot but not the main point (Yoshihara Yuki's works are one good example esp. because of the heavy dose of humor; I know I've read others too but can't think of them right now).

Often it's more like "hentai for girls" and then .

Can't really vote because while smut is not something I seek out, I don't totally avoid it either.

________________
"[English] not only borrows words from other languages; it has on occasion chased other languages down dark alley-ways, clubbed them unconscious and rifled their pockets for new vocabulary."
-James Nicoll, can.general, March 21, 1992

Nay for me.
Sometimes the love making is ridiculous? Yes, I've read some smut but I stop halfway.. it's too embarassing.
Shoujo is meant for innocent and naive girls I supposed? With their cliche romance and bla-bla? xD
I think, it's okay if the smut is show halfway and not too details because this is not targeted to older reader.
So, NAY

I knew I missed something. T~T I would have voted sometimes too. I failed at my own poll. O_O

Someone please edit the options and add sometimes. Thank you~



________________

Monkeys, always at your service.

Nay.
I only like a few certain smut manga. Especially Yoshihara Yuki~ +_+
Others are all...
Girl: Oh, I LOVE YOU<33
Guy: Orly? *throws on bed* I rape you, kkay?
Girl: B-but...OK, I love you anyways, we'll be together forever<3333333333
Guy: *secks* Ok. You're annoying me. *pushes and leaves*
Girl: ;_____; B-b-ut you said you love me!

Added the sometimes option.

________________
♪MONSTARR~ will eat all your cookies and steal your bishies~♪ Φ_Φ

I voted yay..... While I dont read manga specifically for the smut, when there is smut I usually dont mind and or enjoy it

Last edited by ExzyruSxxx at 5:43 pm, Sep 13 2009

Shinjo Mayu's work instantly comes to mind...


Thank you~ <3

________________

Monkeys, always at your service.

Yay!!! from me, but you knew that already.

Yay, as long as it doesn't have boring/bad story, stupid characters/situations and BAD ART.

However, it looks like most shoujo and josei smut have those. O_O. Not quite sure as I don't read much smut since it's hard to find good mangas with smut (they usually suck and are boring as hell). O_O

Even seinen romance mangas have smut. If I like the story, I don't mind. But we are talking about shoujo and josei, aren't we?

Nay for now from me. If I want to see sex, I might as well read hentai. There's no need to endure a boring tedious plot, stupid fluff (by the way I hate fluff) and bad art, did I mention bad art?, just to see nothing.

Last edited by base_coat at 6:14 am, Sep 3 2009

Yay! Unless it's totally out of context... No PWP for me!

Sometimes for me. It needs to be used properly to really enjoy the manga. If it's just thrown in there randomly, might as well read hentai.

very big YAY!!!

http://ayachanya.blogspot.com

Heh, I didn't vote, but it's YAY for me.

Yeah, I am a virgin, but for some reason, I love it.... I dunno why, but I do. :-x

Last edited by StarAngel125 at 1:52 pm, Sep 14 2009

________________
I read so much mangas, I'm too lazy to watch anime!

Manga I'm loving ATM: Heart no Kuni no Alice

YAY!

It's best when it's throughout the entire manga and it has that sort of aura (i.e. Yoru Made Matenai), instead of popping out of nowhere. Smut in shoujo can get really smutty, I like that, but when it's smut but barely any sexual content/girly girly swoon swoon...phail i.e. Stroke Material

________________