manga04_jpg login_tab_left_jpg
Username:   Password:    Forgot Password?
Try out our new iPhone application!
Manga Poll
When I read an unknown word or complicated term, I typically...
Gloss over it and don't bother looking it up
Use Google and read the first result
Go old-school and use a dictionary
Use Wikipedia (or an encyclopedia) and read everything about it as well as the related stuff
See Old Polls

Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!

Coded in ConTEXT

Join #baka-updates

RSS Feed
center_left_tab Forums center_right_tab

You are now viewing a topic.

Skills over Plot

Back to I'm Looking For...

Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!
From User Message Body
Post #591746

4:31 am, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 191


You know how most of the times mangas don't give you a reason for why the protagonist is so amazing, great, genius, etc? Why did he win or loose, no one knows. Nor does anyone know why he is labeled one in 10 years.

I want it explained. Like, for sword skills, I don't want them just waving their swords around according to special effects. I don't want to see them swing and suddenly earth splits apart. I mean, he's cutting air, it's not physically possible that the earth splits if you don't somehow summon an earthquake, right? So for sword skills, I want to see them winning by skillfully using the laws of physics. I want to see them DODGE! That's the very basic damn it! Parry the enemy attacks, footwork, turn enemy strength into his own, etc! That make sense? I mean, martial arts does exist in real life, so if he's not a mage, don't make him look like one.

Or, for things like sports. You often see them yelling out a name "blah blah blah!!!" and suddenly the opponent is defeated. Makes you think there is no skill involved.

It doesn't have to be martial arts or sports, just giving examples. Those two are especially bad in this area with the overuse of special effects.

In short, I don't want the plot ruling over the skills. I don't want the chars to win or loose only because that's part of the story. I don't want to see them defeating the demon king n times stronger only because of the plot. I suppose this might be better defined in animes? Considering there's animation rather than snapshots like manga panels. But either is fine.

Some examples, though to be honest, I don't remember myself how much they fit.
Liar Game (drama)
YuGiOh (anime)

Bad examples:
Phi Brain
many, many martial arts and sports manga

Prince of Tennis, the original anime series is one of the better sports, but went completely downhill for all of the sequels.

Last edited by renseih at 4:39 am, Mar 21

User Posted Image
Post #591748

4:51 am, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 21

i know your pain bro. But mental aspect is a key in sports, but there are a lot that does it really well, shounen magazin is amazing for that.
Tour(short but the one of the best, and there are no suddenly power up, got me tottaly addicted to cycling)
One outs, same author of liar game.
Last inning, the best baseball manga in that aspect
Gigant killing, there a lot into mental aspect of the game, but it's not i win my friendship power nor tsubasa like super skills.
Daiya no A, really well done baseball manga, and get better as it goes, a lot better.
Baby Steps, the protagonist uses his tactics to compensate for lack of experience.

Post #591751
user avatar

5:06 am, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 92

The world god only knows protagonist uses dating sims experience to get the girls
slam dunk uses basics to beat experienced players

I like turtles
Post #591769

8:32 am, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 191

I've already read One Outs and Last Inning. Loved One Outs, one of the best sports mangas. Didn't realize it was the same author as Liar Game though, since the art was a lot better. I only watched the drama of Liar Game since the art was unbearable...

I got recommended Baby Steps quite a few times already, just never seem to get very far in it. As for The World God Only Knows, always thought it was ecchi, but guess I was wrong.

Will check the others out!
Isn't there any non-sports mangas though?

User Posted Image
Post #591770

8:47 am, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 121

Watch Sword Art Online, the Anime, and if you don`t mind Novels you can also read it^^, and in holyland they explain the moves the MC makes

Post #591771
user avatar

8:52 am, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 12

I know exactly the right manga for you. Holyland the art is not that great (it's good to me at least but I guess if liar game was unbearable for you, you'll find this one challenging) and the manga is wordy but it has every thing else you want.

Post #591783

2:32 pm, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 14

All-rounder Meguru is very realistic in that regard.

Post #591784
user avatar
Art is a blast!

2:45 pm, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 581

Baby Steps is exactly what your looking for, mc uses his brain + practice to win, and he doesn't always win, it is the most realistic tenis manga i've ever seen
edit: forgot to say Over Drive another good 1 following what you want

User Posted Image
User Posted Image
3DS FC: 0318-9005-3932 :Add me (pm your fc if you do)
Post #591786

2:55 pm, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 23

Ookiku Furikabutte I'm pretty sure this fits, but I haven't read it in a while.

Post #591787 - Reply to (#591784) by aclgrafix
user avatar

2:57 pm, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 210


Post #591788 - Reply to (#591787) by mybackhurtz
user avatar

3:30 pm, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 247

Quote from mybackhurtz

Seconded. Highly realistic martial arts.

User Posted Image
Post #591792
user avatar

4:00 pm, Mar 21 2013
Posts: 708

Kurogane (IKEZAWA Haruto) is a sports manga (kendo). Protag has a ghost as a master but that's all the supernatural it has.

Is this me in a nutshell?
Pretty much.
User Posted Image
Post #592731

12:24 am, Mar 29 2013
Posts: 43

blood and steel city of darkness a lot of chinese manga do what you are looking for

User Posted Image
Post #592735
user avatar

1:11 am, Mar 29 2013
Posts: 538

Red Eyes
Gunka no Baltzar

Post #592903
user avatar

8:46 am, Mar 30 2013
Posts: 82

Moonlight sculptor(Novel). This novel really explains as to how the main character wins his enemy to the finest detail. Of course if you do nto want novel... Then:

Are a few mangas that you may like.

"you must prove more patient than a caterpillar, more willing to survive than a cockroach, and more stubborn than a leech - or you will definitely fail" - Counselor Rodriguez, the Star of Wisdom
Pages (2) [ 1 2 ] Next You must be registered to post!

Back to I'm Looking For...  Back to Top

Search This Topic:
Manga Search