1) Fellow Melancholic fans
2) Information about the manga--is it worth reading? Is it anything like the anime?
Thanks for your time! ^^
Manga Poll
Manga is the Japanese equivalent of comics
with a unique style and following. Join the revolution! Read some manga today!
Join #baka-updates @irc.irchighway.net
RSS Feed
Forums
The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya fan seeking...
You must be registered to post!
From User
Message Body
Member
8:30 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts: 9
Member
8:51 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts: 555
I haven't read too much of the manga but if you want true Suzumiya Haruhi greatness, read the translated novels.
________________
https://twitter.com/Hostile
________________
https://twitter.com/Hostile
9:00 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts: 2658
I love the novel! It's good stuff.
Member
9:42 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts: 91
1) Yes [I've watched the anime a couple times 
and I've read the first volume of the manga]
2) I find the manga to lack some of the flair the anime delivers. HOWEVER, this is only due to the limitations of images versus video. The play of emotions and events is offsetable yet still understandable in the anime. In the manga, the story is straightforward and the revolutionary aspect of the anime is not really instilled in the manga. IN THE END, the manga is fun to follow if you are really a haruhi fan
________________
∧∧ ∩
( ´∀｀)/
⊂ ﾉ
(つ ﾉ
(ノ
and I've read the first volume of the manga]2) I find the manga to lack some of the flair the anime delivers. HOWEVER, this is only due to the limitations of images versus video. The play of emotions and events is offsetable yet still understandable in the anime. In the manga, the story is straightforward and the revolutionary aspect of the anime is not really instilled in the manga. IN THE END, the manga is fun to follow if you are really a haruhi fan
________________
∧∧ ∩
( ´∀｀)/
⊂ ﾉ
(つ ﾉ
(ノ
Member
9:48 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts: 486
9:48 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts: 486
there is a website where the novels are getting translated and available for reading online
________________
| One Punch Man | Noblesse | Nanatsu no Taizai | Gun x Clover |
________________
| One Punch Man | Noblesse | Nanatsu no Taizai | Gun x Clover |
Member
9:54 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts:
9:54 pm, Mar 17 2007
Posts:
Just as every one said here... the novel is pure awesomeness!
Seriously... I actually kinda regret watching the anime now... it spoiled a couple of volumes for me. The correct order should have been the novel and then the anime.
EDIT: I actually didn't bother with the manga... so I can't answer on that. But you really should read the novel
Seriously... I actually kinda regret watching the anime now... it spoiled a couple of volumes for me. The correct order should have been the novel and then the anime.
EDIT: I actually didn't bother with the manga... so I can't answer on that. But you really should read the novel
Member
10:24 pm, Mar 18 2007
Posts: 9
Excellent! Thanks everyone! I was feeling rather skeptic about the novels, but I'll go for it now!
SyaoranX--where did you find the manga? I've been searching for it, but the sites listed here didn't work for me...>.<
Thanks again for replying, everyone! Anyone interested in discussing Haruhi more in depth, just let me know. ^^
SyaoranX--where did you find the manga? I've been searching for it, but the sites listed here didn't work for me...>.<
Thanks again for replying, everyone! Anyone interested in discussing Haruhi more in depth, just let me know. ^^
Member
10:53 pm, Mar 18 2007
Posts: 1
10:53 pm, Mar 18 2007
Posts: 1
Tbh the manga is so so. The novels are flast out best, but the manga only covers as much as the anime and the anime covers it much better with better feeling conversion from novel to other media. Also, this is the second attempt I believe at a manga development for haruhi suzumiya. The first one was forsaken by the author of the novels and was canceled.
Member
11:02 pm, Mar 18 2007
Posts: 9
Quote:
The first one was forsaken by the author of the novels and was canceled
o.O Yikes.
The first one was forsaken by the author of the novels and was canceled
o.O Yikes.
Member
6:36 am, Mar 22 2007
Posts: 52
The best translation going of the novels is at:
http://baka-tsuki.net It's very good work.
________________
http://senile-seinen.blogspot.com/
http://baka-tsuki.net It's very good work.
________________
http://senile-seinen.blogspot.com/
Member
6:42 am, Mar 22 2007
Posts: 9
The novel is good, so is the anime, I only read a few chapters of the manga, but there was nothing there that the novel or anime didn't do better.
________________
Hell is other people.
________________
Hell is other people.
Member
4:21 pm, Mar 23 2007
Posts: 52
After having read five of the eight Haruhi novels, I watched a few eps of the anime. The anime really just kind of was a travelogue. "here's the club room, Here's Mikuru's maid costume, here's the baseball game, here's the movie, here's the island..." Really, between the illustrations in the novel and the author's prose, there wasn't anything I hadn't already seen before watching.
Now this is no bash on the Anime. Kyoto Animation did a great job. Indeed, I don't think it could have been done any better without a change of script. If you're not into reading translated Japanese novels, the anime will at least get you the meat, if not the sauce of the books. But the subtlety of a lot of things is lost in the anime. Things like Nagato's almost-but-not-quite emotionlessness and Mikuru's pathetic helplessness are not to be seen.
I've got to say that a manga of this material strikes me as the worst of both worlds - Kyon's narrative personality (all of his quirky references to odd literary, historical, and mythological things, for instance) would be hard to get into a manga, and you'd lose the colorful richness of Kyoto Animation's work, too. Maybe Kojima Akira could manage it (He's the guy who did Mahoraba), or the woman who did Kare Kano, but most mangakas couldn't pull it off well.
________________
http://senile-seinen.blogspot.com/
Now this is no bash on the Anime. Kyoto Animation did a great job. Indeed, I don't think it could have been done any better without a change of script. If you're not into reading translated Japanese novels, the anime will at least get you the meat, if not the sauce of the books. But the subtlety of a lot of things is lost in the anime. Things like Nagato's almost-but-not-quite emotionlessness and Mikuru's pathetic helplessness are not to be seen.
I've got to say that a manga of this material strikes me as the worst of both worlds - Kyon's narrative personality (all of his quirky references to odd literary, historical, and mythological things, for instance) would be hard to get into a manga, and you'd lose the colorful richness of Kyoto Animation's work, too. Maybe Kojima Akira could manage it (He's the guy who did Mahoraba), or the woman who did Kare Kano, but most mangakas couldn't pull it off well.
________________
http://senile-seinen.blogspot.com/
Blah
Member
8:23 pm, Jan 30 2009
Posts: 910
As a Haruhist, I have to say that the anime wasn't bad, but the novels were way better (translations can be found at baka-tsuki).
________________
Lalala~
________________
Lalala~
Mad With a Hat
Member
3:15 am, Jan 31 2009
Posts: 4764
Moved to the right forum.
On topic here: I didn't enjoy it. (the manga)
Last edited by NightSwan at 4:00 am, Jan 31 2009
________________
Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
Click 'n Play!
If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.
On topic here: I didn't enjoy it. (the manga)
Last edited by NightSwan at 4:00 am, Jan 31 2009
________________
Hrodulf and Bjornolfr, you will not be forgotten.
And if the world were black and white,
you would be my rainbow in shades of grey.
Click 'n Play!
If I had a fantasy self, it'd be a tentacle monster.
You must be registered to post!
