Quote from Stealth
@frustratedguy109
Your 2 list don't really make sense... when you add stuff you would usually expect to see some stuff ranking to go down and not go up like it was the case with vagabond and eden. (Although I do agree with both your list)
And why does Kiseiju only appear on the second list (it is a SEINEN even in the database)... argh my brain it hurts...
Your 2 list don't really make sense... when you add stuff you would usually expect to see some stuff ranking to go down and not go up like it was the case with vagabond and eden. (Although I do agree with both your list)
And why does Kiseiju only appear on the second list (it is a SEINEN even in the database)... argh my brain it hurts...
Well, they went up because I also took some things off the first list. YKK, Emma, and Genshiken are all listed as seinen in the database, but for me they just don't give me a seinen feeling. Maybe I just haven't read enough, but when I think of seinen, the first thing that pops into my mind is a gritty plot.
And Kiseijuu only shows up on the second list because there's no room for it on my first list... I just don't like it as much as Vagabond, though it is really good.